South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Big Jean Studd]

Also just had a duh moment in regards to Poyser so update to my read: I don't see why he'd pull the executioner on Smark when that's who he was pushing at all lmao and I'm assuming that's a scum role.

Yeah that would be kinda baffling to me. Noted sky was also on Smark too but idk not as sold she wouldn't

Yeah it would pretty fucking dumb from poyserbto waste that shit

 

[Chris]

Yeah it would pretty fucking dumb from poyserbto waste that shit

I'm only worried I might be looking at it too selfishly bc I was also starting to push Smark myself to the extent I voted him too, surely just on thread presence Poyser would save the execute and think Smark was going anyway?

Booty and Grim were the other wagons I think and annoyingly I do read them town atm but just strategically, maybe scum pulled the trigger bc they were worried it could sway? Idk I don't really remember end of day thread mood with all the chaos happening

 

[Chris]

Just did a rough skim and we're not too high on posts for our 40 limit, Poyser could probs try and combine a few of his into one tho got like 25-30 left each eyeballing it tho

Content with my votes that I locked in and that read post with the updated Poyser one, I'm content trusting him for now for sure. Also to a much lesser extent don't think Jean would have used it yet either idk there tho it was a chaos game anyway and I can see him saying fuck it for the lulz. Reevaluating the execution is having me feel better about them both and Poyser especially tho

POE of Sky, Brett, Wang, Lethal first, not sold on the order tho

 

[Just Juice]

​

MEMBERS OF THE SOUTH PARK GOVERMENT HAVE REACHED TWO DECISIONS SO FAR

1) Tremendez has been offered forgiveness and at the end of the night his alignment will change to South Park Aligned.

2) It has been determined that Barry will be fired from the South Park Government at the end of Night One: this will mean closure of the Ministry of Defense

ONE DECISION IS YET TO BE DETERMINED

3) Change the rules for Day Two - so there is a majority hammer or let the rules remain as they are.
​

 

[Chris]

I didn't really consider the department would be closed but I've not been given any indication mine does anything so hopefully that's fine lol

 

[Chris]

Just did a rough skim and we're not too high on posts for our 40 limit, Poyser could probs try and combine a few of his into one tho got like 25-30 left each eyeballing it tho

Content with my votes that I locked in and that read post with the updated Poyser one, I'm content trusting him for now for sure. Also to a much lesser extent don't think Jean would have used it yet either idk there tho it was a chaos game anyway and I can see him saying fuck it for the lulz. Reevaluating the execution is having me feel better about them both and Poyser especially tho

POE of Sky, Brett, Wang, Lethal first, not sold on the order tho

Again reevaluating the execution I actually feel better about booty too. He has a post thinking he'd look bad if Smark did die bc he seemed to naturally assume with the most votes that Smark would. I feel like if he knew about the executioner role before hand he would have been more like "oh what has happened" and have been paranoid saying something like "RIP Smark" would look really bad. To the same extent Troop's reaction that I commented on in real time to town read him for looks better knowing what happened too but I was already kinda hard town reading him so no change there lol

 

[Chris]

Dammit I should have put this in my last post to not waste one with the limit but let me make it very clear all of my reads I'm making that are purely based on Smark's execution are FULLY ASSUMING the execution was a scum role, and with Smark already flipping indie that's very likely but if for some God forsaken reason another executioner indie or town fuck flips, disregard any reason I cleared these people related to the execution lol I just don't know with this game

As long as that never happens I stand by these reads currently though lmao

 

[Poyser]

Not a bad observation about Booty. Though you'd have to say, if they pulled the trigger solely because they were worried it would sway, it pretty much has to be booty or sky. That said, using the execute early D1 on a high vocal player is kind of a no brainer even if scum were safe. My only contention is smark was on 3 votes for quite a while, so not sure why they didn't pull the trigger even earlier

 

[Poyser]

Also I'd kind of appreciate it if people could vote Troop or me for the BP vest, for reasons that will become clear as the game goes on lol. Troop is most town read so probably makes more sense to go him, although I am by far the most likely one to be shot lmao

You don't have to reply to this post btw, don't wanna give any info or whatever but plz consider it anybody reading this

 

[Chris]

Not a bad observation about Booty. Though you'd have to say, if they pulled the trigger solely because they were worried it would sway, it pretty much has to be booty or sky. That said, using the execute early D1 on a high vocal player is kind of a no brainer even if scum were safe. My only contention is smark was on 3 votes for quite a while, so not sure why they didn't pull the trigger even earlier

Well I said Grim or Booty bc they are the other wagons from what I remembered. I just still feel town on both tho, data isnt beating vibes here yet. Sky tbh I was very much suspecting but I can't remember how much of that I said in the thread vs just thought in my head lol but yeah that's why I'm not really giving her the same weight as you for Smark being executed when she was also voting him

 

[Poyser]

vote switch to majority btw

 

[Just Juice]

NIGHT ONE

Countdown Timer

Countdown to Feb 14, 2026 12:16 am. Showing days, hours, minutes and seconds ticking down to 0

www.timeanddate.com

- for all actions
- government votes
- bulletproof vest votes​

 

[Just Juice]

MEMBERS OF THE SOUTH PARK GOVERMENT HAVE REACHED TWO DECISIONS SO FAR

1) Tremendez has been offered forgiveness and at the end of the night his alignment will change to South Park Aligned.

2) It has been determined that Barry will be fired from the South Park Government at the end of Night One: this will mean closure of the Ministry of Defense

ONE DECISION IS YET TO BE DETERMINED

3) Change the rules for Day Two - so there is a majority hammer or let the rules remain as they are.​

 

[Chris]

@Barry Poppins you can't vote hybrid btw lol

 

[Barry Poppins]

Boo, lame.

Vote: Current Setting