South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Poyser]

If Smark stays dead I feel like I fail to see what the point of doing anything with him is lol

just allows him to win with us

 

[Poyser]

we should all leave legacies before end of night obv btw

 

[Poyser]

I will say I kinda started to doubt jean throughout my readback, thought he was pretty passive and shit. then he immediately voted to add me to the council which I would say I think he'd more than likely look for an excuse not to do that as scum lol

 

[Chris]

we should all leave legacies before end of night obv btw

Hey speaking of this, I had one of them D1 roles too where I could have left a last will where when I die it would show up...but it locked at the end of D1 so I was just informed it's gonna be me selecting what chair I wanted when I got invited to this council bc I forgot to do it

So yeah I'll try and leave better actual legacy reads since that's a dud

 

[Poyser]

With smark not being mafia, I think poe for me points for booty/sky both being very likely to be scum

Sky - seems scummy
booty - seems scummy
troop - be shocked if not town, agree with chris 100%
lethal - seems scummy
jean - on balance, probably lean town but wary
wang - felt a little lost from what i saw, tho i will say he always seemed like he knew what was going on when he was scum last game so im thinking probably town
brett - town
barry - town
chris - town

this is probably where im at atm, so poe would be straight

sky
booty
lethal


jean
wang

 

[Barry Poppins]

...uh oh thats not a town Barry post

Shut up bitch

 

[Chris]

We're limited to 40 posts by the way so I'm fine to basically finalize my votes

1. Convert Smark
2. Plurality, you guys go with whatever tho I don't really care lol
3. Fire Grim

Dunno how to lock in, I'll bold that in a bit tho if you guys are down

For reads, I think Sky is my top scum at the moment. I would go there.

I'm sold on Barry and Troop as town, to a lesser extent Booty but I'm still not seeing what you guys are, would def still call town just not as for sure as the other two. troop I would also basically lock, one day he'll burn me for it but until then it's my science lol kinda operating on booty the same way just haven't had the full aha moment

Brett is the one I'm really going back and forth on, def agreed on the entrance bc I went back and read last game but that's why I asked you Poyser how it was handled in the scum chat them. Bc if you were like bruh that was shit we gotta fix this or brought it up after the game, Brett is certainly gonna be super aware of it entering this game.

Jean and Poyser I would rate as paranoid more than anything, very annoying. For Jean I think I've seen some stuff I think MIGHT be tells from the last game he played when he was scum but I'm not sold that they aren't anything he does as town either. There was an early post I can't even remember that kinda read as frustrated scum with setup that pinged me but then I relaxed on that from his future posts. Poyser I feel like I'm vibing with thoughts wise but Smark also wasn't scum. Willing to see if sky is next tho and that'll help with him anyway

Lethal/Wang are both on the radar as potential but just not confident on them yet, lethal did sus sky in his few posts tho so that can be noted

 

[Barry Poppins]

Sky - Leaning Town
Professor Booty - Leaning Scum
R-Troop - Leaning Scum
Lethal - Null
Big Jean Studd - Leaning Town
Wang Chung - Null
Poyser - Null
Brett - Leaning Scum
Chris - Town

That's where I'm at rn.

 

[Barry Poppins]

Vote: Convert Smark
Vote: Hybrid Set-Up
Vote: Fire Grim

 

[Poyser]

We're limited to 40 posts by the way so I'm fine to basically finalize my votes

1. Convert Smark
2. Plurality, you guys go with whatever tho I don't really care lol
3. Fire Grim

Dunno how to lock in, I'll bold that in a bit tho if you guys are down

For reads, I think Sky is my top scum at the moment. I would go there.

I'm sold on Barry and Troop as town, to a lesser extent Booty but I'm still not seeing what you guys are, would def still call town just not as for sure as the other two. troop I would also basically lock, one day he'll burn me for it but until then it's my science lol kinda operating on booty the same way just haven't had the full aha moment

Brett is the one I'm really going back and forth on, def agreed on the entrance bc I went back and read last game but that's why I asked you Poyser how it was handled in the scum chat them. Bc if you were like bruh that was shit we gotta fix this or brought it up after the game, Brett is certainly gonna be super aware of it entering this game.

Jean and Poyser I would rate as paranoid more than anything, very annoying. For Jean I think I've seen some stuff I think MIGHT be tells from the last game he played when he was scum but I'm not sold that they aren't anything he does as town either. There was an early post I can't even remember that kinda read as frustrated scum with setup that pinged me but then I relaxed on that from his future posts. Poyser I feel like I'm vibing with thoughts wise but Smark also wasn't scum. Willing to see if sky is next tho and that'll help with him anyway

Lethal/Wang are both on the radar as potential but just not confident on them yet, lethal did sus sky in his few posts tho so that can be noted

Booty was struggling hard this phase tho. Granted I don’t have a lot of experience with him as a player but he was fine giving thoughts and pretty easygoing in that regard last game. In this game it’s mostly just been excuses for not giving thoughts lol

WRT Brett I’ll go back and check once I’m done in the gym but I don’t think we even discussed his entrance in scum chat with saying it was bad or anything, I just remember I kept telling him to make sure he votes people as that’s something new scum always struggle with

 

[Big Jean Studd]

I will say I kinda started to doubt jean throughout my readback, thought he was pretty passive and shit. then he immediately voted to add me to the council which I would say I think he'd more than likely look for an excuse not to do that as scum lol

Yeah was at work and as said I'm sign ups do have a guest so it's not most optimal time. Then end was ended when I was ready so I didn't really see the point in putting much more effort. Add all the zanyness and I'm having a hard time keeping up with all the roles

And ya obviously if we can add smark back as auto confirmed town its a no shit lol

 

[Chris]

Vote: Convert Smark
Vote: Hybrid Set-Up
Vote: Fire Grim

Can we get some confirmation hybrid is allowed and otherwise I'll do this too lol

 

[Chris]

Also just had a duh moment in regards to Poyser so update to my read: I don't see why he'd pull the executioner on Smark when that's who he was pushing at all lmao and I'm assuming that's a scum role.

Yeah that would be kinda baffling to me. Noted sky was also on Smark too but idk not as sold she wouldn't

 

[Chris]

I asked Juice if we could do Hybrid and I didn't get a direct yes or not but was told the post was clearly defined so I'm taking that as a no

1. Vote: Convert Tremendez
2. Vote: Keep Rules as Is
3. Vote: Fire Grim

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Vote convert tremendez
Vote keep rules as is
Vote fire grim