South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Tremendez]

It’ll be kind of funny to give it to booty because I don’t think he’s scum either and he would just be an hilarious grump on the table.

 

[King Kong Booty]

It’ll be kind of funny to give it to booty because I don’t think he’s scum either and he would just be an hilarious grump on the table.

Hard pass

 

[Big Jean Studd]

As an aside can I say I also think we need to stop using "coaching " as an attack or defense. Brett and Wang were scum and neither suddenly changed their scum game because poyser was there to lead. Most scum mates just play and if anything we should look for planned coordinated moves as opposed to saying "well scum mates wouldn't let him say that " when we know time and time again that's not how it ever goes down in the scum chat unless you're talking a paralyzed newbie which no one is here

 

[Tremendez]

Hard pass

I don’t think you have much choice in it, but I’ll respect your choice and not vote for you.

 

[Chris]

Fair. So Brett?

Eh probs Grim instead jokes aside. But he's going to be just as frustrating to me either way lol

My top town rn are probably booty and Grim, booty would probably kill us if we put him on the council bc it's extra work for him so let's rule him out I guess.

I would do Brett or poyser I think still. Fine with who you and Jean want out of these 4 tho

 

[Barry Poppins]

Lol whateverrrr

 

[Tremendez]

As an aside can I say I also think we need to stop using "coaching " as an attack or defense. Brett and Wang were scum and neither suddenly changed their scum game because poyser was there to lead. Most scum mates just play and if anything we should look for planned coordinated moves as opposed to saying "well scum mates wouldn't let him say that " when we know time and time again that's not how it ever goes down in the scum chat unless you're talking a paralyzed newbie which no one is here

I think that should be using less coaching, but I don’t think we should get rid of it entirely. If they’re playing the same, then I agree with you, but if someone is suddenly playing in a way that you wouldn’t expect them to or playing smarter than you would expect them to then I think you can cause I’m gonna be straight up and be honest with you. I’ve had a mafia game where poser almost verbatim like told me everything to say the entire game and it was hilarious.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Like no one is typing posts out for their scum mates à la magic here I don't think lmao

 

[Tremendez]

Like there was a reads post that he typed up the entire thing for me lol

 

[Chris]

We don't actually know what we even do when we have our 4th so that's fun

 

[King Kong Booty]

Eh probs Grim instead jokes aside. But he's going to be just as frustrating to me either way lol

My top town rn are probably booty and Grim, booty would probably kill us if we put him on the council bc it's extra work for him so let's rule him out I guess.

I would do Brett or poyser I think still. Fine with who you and Jean want out of these 4 tho

This guy gets me but tbh I’m not sure about the other 2

 

[Tremendez]

Like no one is typing posts out for their scum mates à la magic here I don't think lmao

Poyser has in the past. Don’t know if he still cares to.

 

[Barry Poppins]

Knowing South Park we probably do hookers and blow or some shit.

 

[Tremendez]

We don't actually know what we even do when we have our 4th so that's fun

My guess at this juncture since we didn’t get a flip is we might vote on who dies here.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

I think that should be using less coaching, but I don’t think we should get rid of it entirely. If they’re playing the same, then I agree with you, but if someone is suddenly playing in a way that you wouldn’t expect them to or playing smarter than you would expect them to then I think you can cause I’m gonna be straight up and be honest with you. I’ve had a mafia game where poser almost verbatim like told me everything to say the entire game and it was hilarious.

I think to me it's a useless endeavor unless we already have a red flip . Without knowing WHO are teammates, how can we make any real assessment on coaching . Teams full of noobs is a thing that would blow an entire coaching thing null for example