South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Tremendez]

I don’t like troop’s play, but I doubt he’s being coached at all because the reasons I’m getting from him are super easy to pickup and I would hope you’d be getting coached better than that.

 

[King Kong Booty]

I think we should all be comfortable with it so I’m flexible between Brett and Barry. Whatever you guys think is best. i’ve not played a lot of games with Brett so my read on him might not be as valid as yours. Barry though I don’t see any scum tells yet so I’d feel comfortable giving it to him if you’re not sold on Brett.

Neither of them feel as scummy as Sky does

 

[Tremendez]

@Big Jean Studd who are you most comfortable giving the fourth seat to?

 

[Barry Poppins]

You know you can just say "I disagree with your assumption" bc yes it's an assumption which is why I'm articulating the reasons I'm making it so you guys understand. Yes troop COULD do it as scum, I'm saying it's less likely in my mind

Why are you and sky so certain it's scummy play. I never said it's too scummy to be scum, those words were put into my mouth. I think it's simply NOT SCUM PLAY lol

Where did I say I was certain it's scum play? In fact I hadn't even really posted it, I was merely questioning your reasoning because I wanted further expansion on it, which you gave me.

Now who's putting words in my mouth?

 

[Tremendez]

Neither of them feel as scummy as Sky does

I don’t think either are. But picking a council seat is tough.

Definitely not giving it to sky.

 

[King Kong Booty]

Smark Brett Troop and I all have the same level of experience no one’s played with us much

 

[Chris]

The entire game is WIFOM we need to retire that fucking word lmao use your big boy brains and decide on the odds you think something happening are. If they're 70/30, you genuinely do not have to keep entertaining the 30%. Yes you can be wrong and that will suck, but you can't even begin to solve the game if you don't allow yourself to believe some assumptions. That's why I try and find who I think is for sure town first and work on scum after, obviously I can claim someone is wrongfully town but oh well

 

[Tremendez]

Smark Brett Troop and I all have the same level of experience no one’s played with us much

You guys played two or three games before I came back so they seemed to have a little bit more insight on the play than I do. I’ve only played.one.

 

[King Kong Booty]

I don’t think either are. But picking a council seat is tough.

Definitely not giving it to sky.

Oh I misread what you were talking about my bad

 

[Tremendez]

The entire game is WIFOM we need to retire that fucking word lmao use your big boy brains and decide on the odds you think something happening are. If they're 70/30, you genuinely do not have to keep entertaining the 30%. Yes you can be wrong and that will suck, but you can't even begin to solve the game if you don't allow yourself to believe some assumptions. That's why I try and find who I think is for sure town first and work on scum after, obviously I can claim someone is wrongfully town but oh well

Yeah, I hate the WiFOM argument because yeah it is the entire game.

 

[Chris]

Where did I say I was certain it's scum play? In fact I hadn't even really posted it, I was merely questioning your reasoning because I wanted further expansion on it, which you gave me.

Now who's putting words in my mouth?

Grin def town, eyes are about to be clawed out from frustration

Final call

 

[Tremendez]

Grin def town, eyes are about to be clawed out from frustration

Final call

So do you wanna vote him so we can stop the arguing lol

 

[Tremendez]

Because I’m not mad at giving it to Barry I just didn’t think anyone else would agree with me.

 

[Chris]

So do you wanna vote him so we can stop the arguing lol

No I don't want town grim on my council tbh lol

 

[Tremendez]

No I don't want town grim on my council tbh lol

Fair. So Brett?