South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Tremendez]

I think I might vote Brett. I’m struggling to think of somebody that I reasonably think might be town other than Barry but I know nobody trust Barry.

 

[Sky]

It’s interesting as I agree with you, but I also don’t like the way you’re framing it lol

What way am I framing it that's different from you

 

[R-Troop]

Sky is climbing up the ranks of Scum reads no doubt.

Barry Sky Scum sounds plausible.

 

[King Kong Booty]

Bc scum tries to make arguments that they think town is actually likely to follow. Town, and especially Troop from what I've seen from him so far is very conspiratorial and never seems like he cares if people are listening to him, he's solving in his own head

Logical from you here anyone trying to frame it as anything else feels disingenuous

 

[Sky]

Sky is climbing up the ranks of Scum reads no doubt.

Barry Sky Scum sounds plausible.

Do you have any thoughts whatsoever re: Smark pushing you

 

[Barry Poppins]

Bc scum tries to make arguments that they think town is actually likely to follow. Town, and especially Troop from what I've seen from him so far is very conspiratorial and never seems like he cares if people are listening to him, he's solving in his own head

Okay but all you've ever known is town Troop, so I feel like you're gauging it on the premise that scum troop would never do this when we don't know that as a fact.

It's WIFOM if you ask me.

 

[Tremendez]

What way am I framing it that's different from you

The way you’re attacking it as a we can’t go down that road because it’s too WIFOM you’re almost making it seem like we can’t even consider those possibilities which from that perspective I think you’re wrong.

 

[Chris]

I think I might vote Brett. I’m struggling to think of somebody that I reasonably think might be town other than Barry but I know nobody trust Barry.

Barry might be my top town read but idk if i want him on my council

I'll accept Brett but I don't think he's clear from acting different by any means

Let's just do Poyser for fun

 

[Tremendez]

Barry might be my top town read but idk if i want him on my council

I'll accept Brett but I don't think he's clear from acting different by any means

Let's just do Poyser for fun

Poser would be good just to be able to read him, but I don’t trust him at all. I’d probably would be OK with Barry but like you I’m not sure if you’d be good on it lol

 

[Barry Poppins]

Unless maybe you wanna argue that scum Troop would be getting coached, I suppose.

 

[King Kong Booty]

Sky is climbing up the ranks of Scum reads no doubt.

Barry Sky Scum sounds plausible.

I’m not with you on Barry I think he was just grasping at straws and landed on me cuz reasons

 

[Chris]

Okay but all you've ever known is town Troop, so I feel like you're gauging it on the premise that scum troop would never do this when we don't know that as a fact.

It's WIFOM if you ask me.

You know you can just say "I disagree with your assumption" bc yes it's an assumption which is why I'm articulating the reasons I'm making it so you guys understand. Yes troop COULD do it as scum, I'm saying it's less likely in my mind

Why are you and sky so certain it's scummy play. I never said it's too scummy to be scum, those words were put into my mouth. I think it's simply NOT SCUM PLAY lol

 

[R-Troop]

Do you have any thoughts whatsoever re: Smark pushing you

I mean I don't like being voted for at all.

I think he doesn't like my push of Barry but I think he softened a bit once I explained it.

Now am I somewhat vengeful and could think he's scum and wants me out? Yes. Could he and Barry be the Scum team and that's why he voted me? Especially if my conspiracy theory of Smark having some sort of his vote is all that matters? Yes. It's still early.

 

[Tremendez]

I think we should all be comfortable with it so I’m flexible between Brett and Barry. Whatever you guys think is best. i’ve not played a lot of games with Brett so my read on him might not be as valid as yours. Barry though I don’t see any scum tells yet so I’d feel comfortable giving it to him if you’re not sold on Brett.

 

[King Kong Booty]

Unless maybe you wanna argue that scum Troop would be getting coached, I suppose.

Given his work schedule I don’t feel he’s had the time to get coached personally