South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[X-Wang]

This all we have to really go on the two people who are being pushed for a lynch at this time.

 

[Sky]

Knowing I'm town I dislike Barry's position too but for a different reason. Discounting that though because why would scum hit scum with what is undoubtedly a scummy post restriction

 

[X-Wang]

Knowing I'm town I dislike Barry's position too but for a different reason. Discounting that though because why would scum hit scum with what is undoubtedly a scummy post restriction

What if this is his punishment for being voted off the council and not scum targeting him

 

[Big Jean Studd]

I am looking at for the third time of putting it out there the information we can gain.

1. The people pushing the sky lynch if she is town
2. The people who are hard-core defending her if town or scum.

If she is town she would be a target of a scum push as a lynch based upon her play.

If she is scum that helps to clear some of the people from my perspective of pushing her as teammate unless they are bussing her.

The lethal push

1. If town i am going to look at the people who pushed him.

2. If scum we have no one defending his play at all

Of the two we have more people to look at as potential of people being scum.

If I am looking at pairing right now it would be sky/Grim right now based upon how adamant he is that she is town based on what currently.

With lethal I dont have anything other than he is pushing sky.

This is scummy...

Why would we Lynch someone some ppl think might be town over someone no one thinks is town??

That's terrible logic , why are we not lynching the person likeliest to be scum instead of "gaining info"

Dislike. Much dislike.

 

[Barry Poppins]

What if this is his punishment for being voted off the council and not scum targeting him

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Like I am baffled
It's one thing to think sky is scummier but to take a risk more "potential X future info is garbage and potentially fake logic.

Vote who you think is scummier, the hell is this lol

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Wang just shot down my town means for that, feels like completely fake reasoning to vote sky over lethal . Yes I asked but that just makes no sense

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Y'all saying some wack ass shit this phase

 

[X-Wang]

This is scummy...

Why would we Lynch someone some ppl think might be town over someone no one thinks is town??

That's terrible logic , why are we not lynching the person likeliest to be scum instead of "gaining info"

Dislike. Much dislike.

Not scummy at all its me looking at what we have upon. The two. I have my suss on sky which I posted last night to which you said was good case.

I am also looking at the other side as well if she is town I am looking at the opposite. You are suss on Lethal he is also suss to me based upon his lack of play and his perks hurting town

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Not scummy at all its me looking at what we have upon. The two. I have my suss on sky which I posted last night to which you said was good case.

I am also looking at the other side as well if she is town I am looking at the opposite. You are suss on Lethal he is also suss to me based upon his lack of play and his perks hurting town

It is scummy to risk a potential town slot over a slot no one has thought is town.

My issue is more what you said about flips etc , I think it's very bad logic and you literally said out loud no one is defending lethal. Yes we gain info on ppl talking for sky but those ppl could also just be ... wrong.

I'm just failing to see the logic in you outright saying there's no reason to think lethal.is town and yet still choose to go with a non sure thing in sky .

Talking percentages here , I'm not saying metal will flip scum. I'm just struggling to see how you can say that out loud and not think lethal is a better direction. It makes me question the purity of your choice

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Also are people actually hardcore defending sky ? I haven't really seen any all out defenses ? Who are these people defending her outside of grim ? I've said one thing she said was still sky like but I've also said she's seemed soft. I'm not even opposed to lynching sky but the logic some ppl are using is giving me pause lol

 

[Big Jean Studd]

But sky is also kind of no selling it which is also sus if expect her the frenzy here as town

 

[Barry Poppins]

 

[X-Wang]

It is scummy to risk a potential town slot over a slot no one has thought is town.

My issue is more what you said about flips etc , I think it's very bad logic and you literally said out loud no one is defending lethal. Yes we gain info on ppl talking for sky but those ppl could also just be ... wrong.

I'm just failing to see the logic in you outright saying there's no reason to think lethal.is town and yet still choose to go with a non sure thing in sky .

Talking percentages here , I'm not saying metal will flip scum. I'm just struggling to see how you can say that out loud and not think lethal is a better direction. It makes me question the purity of your choice

Yes I did say that based upon looking at both sides as a whole. Me saying that no one has defended lethal is looking at who has voted for who he has interacted with. How can I pair him with anyone in the game. I can pair sky with more people Lethal I have nothing other than his pleasure in making us do some rubber duck crap and his ability to join scum if one died on day 1. Which that could be a lie as well. He could very well be scum.

I can vote either way they are both on my vote list. Neither have filled me with any optimism that they are town.

If scum it clears you more in my eyes and Grim.

Yes you both could be town and wrong about him but I am trying to piece things around what we have. Which is not much currently.

 

[Just Juice]

DAY TWO VOTE COUNT #3

Lethal (3) - Jean, Barry Poppins, Sky
Sky (3) - Booty, Rubber Ducky, Chris, Poyser
Barry (1) - R-Troop

President Vote
Chris (7) - Sky, Barry Poppins, Jean, Booty, Rubber Ducky, Wang, Poyser, Chris
Jean (1) - R-Troop

Vice President Vote
Jean (6) - Sky, Barry Poppins, Jean, Booty, Rubber Ducky, Wang, Poyser
Poyser (2) - R-Troop, Chris

Poyser (1) - Sky
Rubber Ducky (1) - Poyser

Countdown Timer

Counting time since Feb 15, 2026 12:40 am. Showing days, hours, minutes and seconds counting up

www.timeanddate.com

​