South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Tremendez]

I do have to agree with Sky there. I want to see Barry here today.

 

[Chris]

What progression, he's not posted all (realtime) day

I think his sus on Booty is wrong but comes from an ultimately fine place so I can call him town currently

I didn't see where you had commented on him after you initially voted him and said it was a red flag he didn't join on the Brett thing. Seemed like you were sus. This is the progression...even tho he hasn't posted today yes. Thanks for giving it despite acting like I asked a dumb question

 

[Sky]

What exactly makes you think any of them are scum?

What information are you working from at this juncture to make you think that that was a good or a bad push that would give you the justification that you need that you should be scum hunting on that?

I understand you qualified that you were asking follow up questions more so than the un voting but it just seems like an odd premise to start from that pool.

This is exactly why I asked the question instead of accusing anyone. To see who would notice they'd parked on a player whom they'd voted for no reason and who would stick to their guns and act like they'd seen something scummy.

(although since then I have seen something scummy from Brett but that's besides)

 

[Tremendez]

Next question then is about Brett and Troop. They're voting Grim rn, do you think that's a push in good faith?

I do. I actually did address Brett a few seconds ago, but I like where Brett‘s head is at. I like the way that Brett was questioning me. I like the way that Brett addressed the pressure. I think Brett was trying to figure things out. And I think the wagon on him makes sense from his perspective, especially because I think he was trying to pick up on some of the things that I was, but he doesn’t have the experience that I do to realize that grim is probably town at this juncture. I totally forgot about Troop lol let me go back and read his reasons.

 

[Sky]

I didn't see where you had commented on him after you initially voted him and said it was a red flag he didn't join on the Brett thing. Seemed like you were sus. This is the progression...even tho he hasn't posted today yes. Thanks for giving it despite acting like I asked a dumb question

Oh yeah you have to post thoughts in the thread don't you. Silly me

 

[Chris]

Feels like I'm having to pull teeth for reads here, let me specify again I'm okay with weak vibey ones. I want to know everyone's real time thoughts not their safe ones they've thought about forever and think everyone will agree with, let's brainstorm and solve this out loud

 

[Chris]

Oh yeah you have to post thoughts in the thread don't you. Silly me

Instead of your scum chat yes (/s unless I'm right)

 

[Chris]

I quoted a post from Smark yesterday that I said screamed town to me or whatever and now I've convinced myself the reason I read it town could also be scummy so I disregarded it lol I don't think that hurts anyone to see my brain change it's mind in real time, helps me figure out my finals thoughts at least

 

[Tremendez]

We have zero information at this juncture. I don’t give much for reads on day one unless I really feel something and when I really feel something I’ll tell you. No one has to ask me what my reads are if I have one, but if you’re gonna ask me, then I’m gonna give you my general idea of where I’m at right now but it’s not gonna be like based on anything particular, but I feel like my reads on Brett, Grim, Poyser and Sky should suffice. If not, IDK.

Especially my read on Poyser. I don’t feel is particularly safe at all.

 

[Tremendez]

I quoted a post from Smark yesterday that I said screamed town to me or whatever and now I've convinced myself the reason I read it town could also be scummy so I disregarded it lol I don't think that hurts anyone to see my brain change it's mind in real time, helps me figure out my finals thoughts at least

Sounds like you might be overthinking it a bit

But I only say that knowing that I’m not mafia, lol

 

[Tremendez]

Now I’m gonna read back on Troop.

 

[Chris]

Sounds like you might be overthinking it a bit

But I only say that knowing that I’m not mafia, lol

It was a weak post I only town leaned on vibes, feel like you'd agree it's not wise to give someone like you that read so early on D1 even if you aren't town

 

[Chris]

Just for clarification it was about the no majority thing, you did seem genuinely excited that you hadn't realized how the rules would change things but later on you said something about how you play safer as scum and I realized why wouldn't you be excited about the rules then as well. You would hate being lynched while you sleep as scum just as much as town and that's what you were glad couldn't happen here

 

[Tremendez]

It was a weak post I only town leaned on vibes, feel like you'd agree it's not wise to give someone like you that read so early on D1 even if you aren't town

If it was early in day 1 then yes, for sure.

 

[Tremendez]

Just for clarification it was about the no majority thing, you did seem genuinely excited that you hadn't realized how the rules would change things but later on you said something about how you play safer as scum and I realized why wouldn't you be excited about the rules then as well. You would hate being lynched while you sleep as scum just as much as town and that's what you were glad couldn't happen here

That makes sense. I want to say that your instinct on the first one is probably closer, but I will say that yes as scum I probably would be happy that I couldn’t be lynched at night, but I’m gonna be honest with you when I made that post it was more so because I didn’t want to be miss lynched during night as if I’m scum it’d be kind of a relief, not having to worry about defending a legitimate case against me

That being said, I was legitimately happy when I found out about that rules changing strategy because I do think it changes the ability to scum hunt. If you can put pressure on people when you don’t have to always vote to Lynch and yes, I know other people don’t always, but that’s how I always look at it anytime I place a vote I’m placing a vote if I think that this could maybe lead to a hammer. Believe me if you will, though. Of course. Don’t think that’s an iron clad read and can be either for sure.