South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Tremendez]

I didn't want to go too hard on the three people who never unvoted Brett because there's three of them and they're unlikely to all be scum. Instead I took the tack of just asking questions and seeing whose response to the reminder I liked.

(for the record: only Jean's)

What exactly makes you think any of them are scum?

What information are you working from at this juncture to make you think that that was a good or a bad push that would give you the justification that you need that you should be scum hunting on that?

I understand you qualified that you were asking follow up questions more so than the un voting but it just seems like an odd premise to start from that pool.

 

[Tremendez]

Fwiw as an aside I found Sky's post about "oh the four best players are town.yay" not paranoid enough in the least. Odds are one of us should be scum by pure percentage lol

Also not a fan of the follow up where Sky said don’t ask me why it’s just vibes because again if the only reasons are vibes that’s not paranoid enough.

 

[Tremendez]

My tldr is smark was byddying me and speaking for me to Barry, and I think poyser point there is ok but I don't really put much stock in smark making a mistake and "lying".

I'm not sure how I even feel about poyser asking me what I thought as my paranoid side is like "is he waiting to push but wants my blessing " which is obviously scummy . But he could also genuinely want my thoughts lol

I have a genuine question for you outside of my defense before that I would just wouldn’t do that, but if I was a scum, what would I get out of that?

Have you earned yourself a position in the thread where you’ve already seen to be super town to the point that I would put myself in that position to buddy you while doing this back-and-forth with Barry and has Barry already put him himself in a position where he looked already super guilty? I don’t think that play makes any sense from my point of view if I was scum unless those two points are true.

 

[Chris]

Need you to get to the part of the thread where I say I just want reads on everyone else and that more defending will bore me trying to solve is the best defense for my suspicion, just make me think I'm barking up the wrong tree lol I know it's hard not to reply to every post saying anything about you but it really doesn't help me read you any when you do

 

[Tremendez]

So, I was skimming through and is the gift just a bulletproof vest for some reason?

Seems like a bad idea to reveal that if true.

 

[Tremendez]

Need you to get to the part of the thread where I say I just want reads on everyone else and that more defending will bore me trying to solve is the best defense for my suspicion, just make me think I'm barking up the wrong tree lol I know it's hard not to reply to every post saying anything about you but it really doesn't help me read you any when you do

I’m responding to the poses. I read them but basically every post in here is talking about me because you guys keep asking about me lol

 

[Tremendez]

But I honestly want an answer to that Jean question because I don’t think the buddying accusation makes any sense whatsoever and I’d like to hear what’s Jean‘s thought is on that.

 

[Tremendez]

I’m responding to the poses. I read them but basically every post in here is talking about me because you guys keep asking about me lol

To the posts as I read them*

 

[Chris]

I’m responding to the poses. I read them but basically every post in here is talking about me because you guys keep asking about me lol

Yeah I know it's counter intuitive to how you always play but genuinely I know what you're probably going to say to them bc you're not bad at defending yourself as scum anyway. What's harder is game solving.

What are your thoughts on Booty and Grim, they are the only two wagons going rn I think other than yourself

 

[Chris]

And do you still think Poyser is town

 

[Tremendez]

Yeah I know it's counter intuitive to how you always play but genuinely I know what you're probably going to say to them bc you're not bad at defending yourself as scum anyway. What's harder is game solving.

What are your thoughts on Booty and Grim, they are the only two wagons going rn I think other than yourself

I couldn’t tell you a single thing about booty because I’ve not played a lot of games with him and honestly the only thing he keeps posting right now is how much he hates how confusing the game is right now lol as for Grim, I haven’t seen anything yet. I’m usually pretty good at picking him up as scum, which is why I was trying to rattle him so much earlier. I think he looks good at the moment, but I would like to see more from him cause I don’t think he’s posted today.

Sky, I got some thing to work with which is why I’ve also been asking Sky some questions so I’ll get back to you on sky, but I’m not a super big fan of some of the way Sky is going about things so I’ll see you when Sky comes back in here.

 

[Tremendez]

And do you still think Poyser is town

Not particularly.

I think anyone that gives him a town read on day one is being foolish. Casing point me last game when I trusted him way too early. Now most of his stuff is gonna be based on me so take that for what you will because he’s not doing too much outside of me, but you brought up that he dropped the lying thing, but I don’t think he ever actually really addressed it and just pretty much ignored it, including when I tried to bring up to him that his timeline didn’t make the most sense because I didn’t even push it the way that he was claiming that I was pushing it until I was asked to clarify by a third-party later and he just really never addressed it even when I brought it to his attention so that’s not particularly good for me. And also, I don’t think he’s done a whole lot since then. Me even saying this means he’s probably just gonna come harder at me but whatever.

 

[Sky]

@Sky have you had any progression on Barry, what are the current thoughts there

What progression, he's not posted all (realtime) day

I think his sus on Booty is wrong but comes from an ultimately fine place so I can call him town currently

 

[Tremendez]

I’m feeling better about Brett. He does not look like he did last game and he think he’s trying to figure things out today. I’m not sure I like lethal too much. I have to go back and reread his posts.

 

[Chris]

I couldn’t tell you a single thing about booty because I’ve not played a lot of games with him and honestly the only thing he keeps posting right now is how much he hates how confusing the game is right now lol as for Grim, I haven’t seen anything yet. I’m usually pretty good at picking him up as scum, which is why I was trying to rattle him so much earlier. I think he looks good at the moment, but I would like to see more from him cause I don’t think he’s posted today.

Sky, I got some thing to work with which is why I’ve also been asking Sky some questions so I’ll get back to you on sky, but I’m not a super big fan of some of the way Sky is going about things so I’ll see you when Sky comes back in here.

Next question then is about Brett and Troop. They're voting Grim rn, do you think that's a push in good faith?