South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Poyser]

Booty is probably town. I don't think he softs as scum like that, its not a play he's seen much of and even if a teammate recommended it, they wouldn't say do it now

meh
if he's a bomb as mafia then I think he'd want to use that to threaten people off voting for him. dont think you need to be a seasoned player to have that thought process.

 

[X-Wang]

You missed Wang. That's it. I assume you have him as a full on scum read correct? (Note the sarcasm)

I am town.

 

[Brett]

Spending like 30 minutes merging my notes into a manifesto just to have no one react to it, that's it you're all scum.

 

[King Kong Booty]

Spending like 30 minutes merging my notes into a manifesto just to have no one react to it, that's it you're all scum.

I’d like to say I liked it

 

[Poyser]

@Poyser walk me through the Smark thing bc I don't see where the lie would have really screamed scum to me still, we know town is just simply wrong a lot

I will say I'm softening on Smark a bit, but as I've said it wasn't him getting his facts wrong that rubbed me up wrong, it's what he went for which was discrediting me rather than just defending himself. It's not the main crux of my feelings on him, but it did add to the weirdness I felt around his play around jeff early on, combined with him seeming a bit unnatural when feeling the need to justify his blind vote on brett

 

[X-Wang]

Spending like 30 minutes merging my notes into a manifesto just to have no one react to it, that's it you're all scum.

I just gave it a like.

 

[Poyser]

You brought the booty stuff up out of nowhere. It's booty, he seems something negative about him he's going to have a reaction for it. So yes it's bait

he didn't react at all to me shading him tho
and when jeff called him out for it, he just defended why he didn't react to it. he still didn't say anything to/about me lol

 

[Tremendez]

I will say I'm softening on Smark a bit, but as I've said it wasn't him getting his facts wrong that rubbed me up wrong, it's what he went for which was discrediting me rather than just defending himself. It's not the main crux of my feelings on him, but it did add to the weirdness I felt around his play around jeff early on, combined with him seeming a bit unnatural when feeling the need to justify his blind vote on brett

Did you read me clarifying that it wasn’t the timetable though. In my response to you, I didn’t bring that up at all. It wasn’t until a little bit later when Jean asked me why I no sold you that I then brought it up as a secondary context.

Originally I only addressed your point.

 

[Poyser]

Also can I just put it on the record I think rabbit ears is a shit scum hunting theory lol

the only time it ever actually works is when the person doing it makes it obvious they've been sat in the thread reading the whole time lol

 

[King Kong Booty]

he didn't react at all to me shading him tho
and when jeff called him out for it, he just defended why he didn't react to it. he still didn't say anything

I didn’t see it

 

[R-Troop]

troop also day targeted me with something right at the start too lol, and he didn't respond to me asking why he chose me

I didn't reply the first time because I didn't want to throw it out there yet.

But now I don't have a choice.

Why did I do it? I wanted to choose an experienced player to target.

 

[Chris]

meh
if he's a bomb as mafia then I think he'd want to use that to threaten people off voting for him. dont think you need to be a seasoned player to have that thought process.

I have no data bc he's never been Mafia but I think he would have tried to be more patient, it was fairly early. I don't buy that he'd be a bad team player as scum like Barry was saying. It really has nothing to do with the role, this kind of goes just with him throwing out any role hint in that situation. I'm expecting a more reserved booty the first time he draws scum, he's gonna want to win more than he remembers he needs to act like a dick, or at least is what I'm going off of until I'm proven wrong lol

 

[Poyser]

I think I'm null on wang and poyser, have a slight town read on anyone else that's posted if I haven't said so yet. Sky is the only one I've gotten red flag from, mostly from that sequence I quoted with the Brett voting and unvoting. Only real sus rn

dont mind the sus on sky either, she's been soft

 

[Brett]

Spot on Chris, you and I have the exact same read on Booty. Not to glaze

 

[Chris]

dont mind the sus on sky either, she's been soft

Since you're hear and updated your thoughts I'll elaborate on you too. The Smark stuff felt opportunistic to me but your recent post did cover that. I thought the other stuff was weird too, but I can mostly rationalize it from him as I talked out in the thread