South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Poyser]

I'm not comfortable reading Grim at all. He admitted to me the last game we were both town that even when he's town and he thinks someone is scum, he grasps at anything and everything to try and convince people of that, and I always sus when I think someone is reaching to prove some kind of concrete read. Genuinely can't reconcile that lmao my old rule was he's more reasonable as town but pretty sure his last scum game that I spectated recently he played the exact same so in my head I said fuck it he was town lmao

I can say most of his posts on Jean regarding the Brett push were what I would deem not very reasonable from Grim, I just gotta figure out if that's town or scum still

my (albeit old) meta was actually that he was more reasonable as scum. when he was town his posts made me want to tear my eyeballs out

 

[X-Wang]

I was scum last game and that was the only game I played with him. He does seem slightly different and I am trying to see if it based upon him working or not.

And the other game I played as scum he wasnt in. I do see the vengeful thing as more of a town role so he can be higher on my town side and not someone I would vote today

 

[King Kong Booty]

I was scum last game and that was the only game I played with him. He does seem slightly different and I am trying to see if it based upon him working or not.

You fucks killed me night one how much time did I get to play for me to be so different?

 

[Chris]

my (albeit old) meta was actually that he was more reasonable as scum. when he was town his posts made me want to tear my eyeballs out

I'm only doubting this bc last game or two he was also scum and I said the eyeballs thing so deemed he must be town. Otherwise, yes same meta that Jean agreed with earlier too lol

 

[Poyser]

Smark buddies as town all the time too so for me ya à bit icky but what's the motivation on a player who aren't falls for that. Last game he buddied me as town and I still considered voted him and pushed him.

I think he would auto go for it as scum, because he always wants to stay on the good side of the big hitters. He will defend himself if pushed first, but I believe his first tactic would be to try and buddy/create a camaraderie

 

[X-Wang]

You fucks killed me night one how much time did I get to play for me to be so different?

You were town read by everyone last game so we killed the one person who was most townie in everyone's eyes

 

[Chris]

You were town read by everyone last game so we killed the one person who was most townie in everyone's eyes

Mmm yeah I kinda get your read post more now. You were scum so you never had to read booty so you are only going by everyone saying his play was town last game lol

 

[King Kong Booty]

You were town read by everyone last game so we killed the one person who was most townie in everyone's eyes

Doesn’t change the fact I barely got to play so how am I so different? All you’ve said is everyone thought I was town then and don’t now so that somehow makes sense as to why I’m not town now?

 

[Poyser]

We got thread and PM messengers on D1 lmao

troop also day targeted me with something right at the start too lol, and he didn't respond to me asking why he chose me

 

[Tremendez]

I think he would auto go for it as scum, because he always wants to stay on the good side of the big hitters. He will defend himself if pushed first, but I believe his first tactic would be to try and buddy/create a camaraderie

And you think I do this by parroting a non-case on a day where there’s no majority vote and can’t hammer by having a back-and-forth with another player and putting a large bull’s-eye on myself?

 

[Chris]

troop also day targeted me with something right at the start too lol, and he didn't respond to me asking why he chose me

Oh that's wtf your post was about, I was confused but forgot to ask

 

[Tremendez]

So there’s a lot of day stuff going around.

 

[R-Troop]

Going off what I have seen so far gamewise

Townish
Brett is completely different this game and has decent thoughts so far and not all over the place and doesnt seem paranoid

Chris- seems pretty even keeled and looking things.

Null

Troop- seems slightly different than last game and more relaxed in his posts which I like for him.

Jean-like I mentioned earlier cant put him anywhere yet as I need to see how he plays throughout the game to move one way or another.

Booty- last game everyone town read him right off the bat. This time due to work not as present so maybe its that but just not sure.

Poyser- same as Jean

Lethal- hasnt shown up yet so nothing

Grim- I unsure of right now.

Smark- trying to decide if he is town buddying up or scum buddying up.

Sky- seems like sky also not pointing out things about Poyser like last game and doesnt seem to follow him like last time when she was a stump.

I feel like I missed someone.

You missed Wang. That's it. I assume you have him as a full on scum read correct? (Note the sarcasm)

 

[X-Wang]

Doesn’t change the fact I barely got to play so how am I so different? All you’ve said is everyone thought I was town then and don’t now so that somehow makes sense as to why I’m not town now?

I didn't say you wasn't town. I have you as null with almost everyone. I don't have a full read on your play style to say this is a town Booty. I just went along with them last game as I was scum and knew you was town.

 

[Chris]

You missed Wang. That's it. I assume you have him as a full on scum read correct? (Note the sarcasm)

Hey what did you target poyser with