Your play has been pretty underwhelming since your TP vote on Day 1. Nothing about it is really overly challenging and I would say you haven't really been pushing anything super hard or scum hunting. Just following the crowd. Which edges closer to scum tactics. You also didn't mention Mitch but was fine with voting him after Me/Poyser brought him up.
Just some abnormalities in your play for me. It's making it hard for me to trust you as town, and I can't find any reason to not think you're scum without your vote on TP