AEW Tier list RETURNS! - Let's do a fun one!

[Comrade Khan]

It's time to get back to work and continue this list! I have decided to choose a wrestler that people seem to be a bit more split on then most.

Without further delay, let's begin with this week's Tier Maker vote:

THE SPANISH GOD

Sammy Guevarra

Love him or hate hit, Sammy G is a 3 time TNT winner and a so called "pillar" of AEW.

Have fun!







Current Tier List​

 

[Just Juice]

if Dante is a C - then so is Sammy imo

 

[Comrade Khan]

if Dante is a C - then so is Sammy imo

certainly your opinion. but i will remind you and others that you should try and weigh in Kayfabe/how they are booked. If you consider that, you can't really say they are equal since Sammy has 3 championship wins under his belt. Just something to consider in the future, as it makes for more rich discussions.

also, not to be TOO controversial, but if we were basing this on in ring only I'd probably have Dante higher than Sammy.

 

[Alexa]

I gave Sammy a D, lol, but mainly just because personally see nothing special about it.

I also hate how AJPW did Pillars and now every company is copying that idea as well.

 

[Comrade Khan]

im prob overating Dante's in ring though because he floats

 

[Comrade Khan]

I knew this choice would create some good controversy Easy E ain't got shit on me

 

[Alexa]

I knew this choice would create some good controversy Easy E ain't got shit on me

If I made my own tier list, I would have pitchforks and torches, lol. Because I would have Jericho way lower than A

 

[Comrade Khan]

I'm giving him a solid B myself, 3 time champion but not booked the absolute best (though very strong). He has a good connection with the crowd whether heel or face. His recent booking and his promo ability hurt him here and I hate to say it but he's the "weakest" of the four pillars.

fwiw @War Pig , the 4 pillar thing you can 100% blame MJF on. That's all him that started that for heat and it looks like its working on u

 

[Comrade Khan]

If I made my own tier list, I would have pitchforks and torches, lol. Because I would have Jericho way lower than A

KAYFABE tier list , one must read the assignment before disagreeing

first aew world champion and booked hella strong for year 1. less so now. year one can easily make an argument for S. it's all relative to their booking and their placement in the company for me in this exercise, but that's the beauty of a forum! We can all have different viewpoints and methods how we rate someone and have fun discussions about it!

What don't you like about Sammy and Jericho that makes them lose points to you, for example? I'd love to hear it

 

[Alexa]

fwiw @War Pig , the 4 pillar thing you can 100% blame MJF on. That's all him that started that for heat and it looks like its working on u

Nah, i have seen that stuff on twitter and reddit so as well. And if you want talk about the four or even five pillars of AEW then Sammy wouldn't be one of my picks for it, lol

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Blaze come give your boy an S

 

[Comrade Khan]

Nah, i have seen that stuff on twitter and reddit so as well. And if you want talk about the four or even five pillars of AEW then Sammy wouldn't be one of my picks for it, lol

im more into the 4 killers anyway myself

garcia, yuta, lee, hook

 

[Alexa]

What don't you like about Sammy and Jericho that makes them lose points to you, for example? I'd love to hear it

I will come back to this statement when I have actually gone to sleep, and not been awake for about 16 hours straight, lol

im more into the 4 killers anyway myself

garcia, yuta, lee, hook

Not bad, but I still don't get the appeal of Hook, lol.

 

[Just Juice]

HOOK is the Bart Simpson of pro wrestling...

 

[Comrade Khan]

Hook eats chips, does cool suplexes and has a great theme. he's also Taz's son. Not much else to get