South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Chris]

I mean is poyser the type of player that would take being silenced for a day just to fool us?

No, my only suspicion would be if he was recruited when sky died. We know Brett was skys partner, or I guess he at least said that so I'm assuming who we're looking for is that D2 so annoyingly most of my sky clears are moot now

 

[Barry Poppins]

So Sky and Brett were the two starting scum.

Recruiting Lethal of course would be a horrible idea unless he's lying about his role. Booty would probably also be a less than ideal choice since he was also being suspected of being scum as well.

I think Chris for all intents and purposes can't be scum. If he was recruited I'd be pretty pissed.

I'm the indy, of course.

That really leaves Poyser or Troop to be the last two who feasibly could be recruited and people may not think about it.

 

[Chris]

We basically have to look at play around Brett today to try and find the recruet, our play the first 2 days became mostly meaningless unless it's the exact secario Lethal lied about his recruit being D1 only and he didn't realize it would be announced publically lol and every time I type that out I see how unlikely it would be that lethal does that

 

[Poyser]

wtf lmao

 

[Chris]

So Sky and Brett were the two starting scum.

Recruiting Lethal of course would be a horrible idea unless he's lying about his role. Booty would probably also be a less than ideal choice since he was also being suspected of being scum as well.

I think Chris for all intents and purposes can't be scum. If he was recruited I'd be pretty pissed.

I'm the indy, of course.

That really leaves Poyser or Troop to be the last two who feasibly could be recruited and people may not think about it.

I think you're on the right mindset here but let me specify, lethal said he could be recruited D1 specially, if wasn't scum's choice. So the D2 recruit could have been similar, not picked by scum

 

[King Kong Booty]

So Sky and Brett were the two starting scum.

Recruiting Lethal of course would be a horrible idea unless he's lying about his role. Booty would probably also be a less than ideal choice since he was also being suspected of being scum as well.

I think Chris for all intents and purposes can't be scum. If he was recruited I'd be pretty pissed.

I'm the indy, of course.

That really leaves Poyser or Troop to be the last two who feasibly could be recruited and people may not think about it.

Wang is clear too?

 

[Poyser]

So Sky and Brett were the two starting scum.

Recruiting Lethal of course would be a horrible idea unless he's lying about his role. Booty would probably also be a less than ideal choice since he was also being suspected of being scum as well.

I think Chris for all intents and purposes can't be scum. If he was recruited I'd be pretty pissed.

I'm the indy, of course.

That really leaves Poyser or Troop to be the last two who feasibly could be recruited and people may not think about it.

This reason for clearing Chris makes no sense btw

Also, how do you know they chose who to recruit and it’s not a mechanic Ala what lethal claimed?

 

[X-Wang]

Holy shit he tried to take me out and I was rereading day 1.

The stench of that.

 

[Barry Poppins]

I think you're on the right mindset here but let me specify, lethal said he could be recruited D1 specially, if wasn't scum's choice. So the D2 recruit could have been similar, not picked by scum

That is something to consider as well.

Maybe mass claim time?

 

[Barry Poppins]

Wang is clear too?

Correct.

 

[Chris]

Genuinely tho I think I could have been the D2 recruit from your guys POV as well so I equally should need to win myself back despite the first two days. That's how fucked this recruit is and why I'm so stressed rn bc I can't start to solve it either

 

[Poyser]

Chris I’m not really sure why what he did would make you feel worse about me? You think he’s pulling this shit if I can actually advise him lol?

Like, there’s literally so many things he could have done or tried with that kill and he basically went full r word. He probably wasn’t being advised at all

 

[Poyser]

Correct.

No he’s not lol, have you heard of WIFOM?

 

[Chris]

This reason for clearing Chris makes no sense btw

Also, how do you know they chose who to recruit and it’s not a mechanic Ala what lethal claimed?

Im assuming it's exactly this, lethal either lied and could be recruited later or someone else had the D2 one

 

[Chris]

Chris I’m not really sure why what he did would make you feel worse about me? You think he’s pulling this shit if I can actually advise him lol?

Like, there’s literally so many things he could have done or tried with that kill and he basically went full r word. He probably wasn’t being advised at all

I think you may have caught onto a soft and trying Wang with me is suspicoous in that Brett would do that potentially bc someone else caught on