South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[X-Wang]

Easy solution would be to have him shoot Lethal no?

Yeah it could help solve two problems at once.

 

[X-Wang]

Also if he even does it.

 

[R-Troop]

If Barry survives to Day 4, Town has lost the game.

 

[X-Wang]

If Barry survives to Day 4, Town has lost the game.

Why

 

[Barry Poppins]

Why

Because I'm scum, duh.

 

[King Kong Booty]

I don’t care for Troop not listening to other players logic at all

 

[X-Wang]

Alright so I'll go ahead and be forthcoming.

I'm Mr. Garrison, formerly of town, now made to be "Dead Presidents" aligned. Basically I win with town if Chris dies at any point in the game. I *was* a masonizer, and how unlucky of me, I was going to use it on Smark N1, but then he got executed so I lost my power. I have an additional power, which can basically be a Mayor role, which instead of ending day would just wipe votes clean.

Feel free to vote me out if you like, but here you go, I'm the extra one in that consensus.

Grim if Chris doesnt die which side do you win with? Do you win with either side

 

[Barry Poppins]

Grim if Chris doesnt die which side do you win with? Do you win with either side

I don't win at all.

 

[X-Wang]

I don't win at all.

Ok that makes me feel better about you for the time being.

 

[R-Troop]

Why

It's 5-1-2 right now.

The logical play from scum tonight is to kill Chris, thus ensuring town has to lynch Barry and not scum.

 

[X-Wang]

It's 5-1-2 right now.

The logical play from scum tonight is to kill Chris, thus ensuring town has to lynch Barry and not scum.

Yes but he doesnt win as he is. If Chris dies he becomes town, if Chris doesnt die he is still considered a town number. So it is still basically 6-2.

 

[X-Wang]

He wont win if Chris lives as he has only one win condition and that is for the president to die and he becomes a town member.

 

[X-Wang]

So based upon that information and looking at the board

The people I won't consider for lynch today.

Chris, Poyser, Booty, and myself.

Troop only because of the sky push.

That leaves me with Lethal and Brett.

 

[R-Troop]

Yes but he doesnt win as he is. If Chris dies he becomes town, if Chris doesnt die he is still considered a town number. So it is still basically 6-2.

I read his role as we do not win if he wins.

Maybe I mis-read it? I don't know.

 

[Barry Poppins]

If Chris is still alive at the end of the game, I don't win. If Chris dies at any point, I win *with* town, and town only.

So I'm a town number for all intents and purposes, if not a full town member.