South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[R-Troop]

Hate this from you Troop NGL

I am just bringing up all possible scenarios.

The facts state that Chris had only one vote and it was a killshot.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Vote President: Jean
Vote Vice Predident: Poyser

Why do you think poyser and I are town ?

 

[X-Wang]

He waited to vote until he knew his vote would be a killshot.

That's kinda scummy to me.

I mean he could have had the executioner role, and knew his vote would be the killshot. I think it's a perfectly fair scenario that I'm bringing up.

Am I missing something here? Are you saying that he voted to get to a certain number to use the execution?

I am trying to follow you here. Because I thought it was just a normal vote. I will go back and look at that.

 

[Brett]

Booty why sky
Brett too

One thing we have overlooked is that there was no night kill, I would suspect scum to come in with tight buttholes thinking they are on the chopping block. Sky's defeated posts really rang a certain way with me, again I don't want to pile on if she's going through something, but to me it reads like a "we fucked up" return from night time. She was also the first to come in and was being fairly erratic, and I think played her hand too quickly as we are now seeing.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

One thing we have overlooked is that there was no night kill, I would suspect scum to come in with tight buttholes thinking they are on the chopping block. Sky's defeated posts really rang a certain way with me, again I don't want to pile on if she's going through something, but to me it reads like a "we fucked up" return from night time. She was also the first to come in and was being fairly erratic, and I think played her hand too quickly as we are now seeing.

I See

What are your reads again Brett and why ?

 

[Barry Poppins]

 

[Big Jean Studd]

I'll be back later .

 

[R-Troop]

Why do you think poyser and I are town ?

I have been on the Barry train, and the Sky train. So if I find those 2 to be scum the rest aren't.

I see Poyser playing a totally different game than he did last time.

Am I missing something here? Are you saying that he voted to get to a certain number to use the execution?

I am trying to follow you here. Because I thought it was just a normal vote. I will go back and look at that.

So what I'm trying to say is that Chris could have conceivably had the executioner role. And he would know that 3 votes would end the day and kill Smark. He then pulls the trigger to end the day and kill Smark.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

View attachment 95422

Vote lethal before bed ?

 

[King Kong Booty]

Troop
You seem to be the only one who hasn’t had a town read on Chris this game
Even before you brought this up you had Jean and Poyser higher as town. What is it in Chris’s game that has you off on him?

 

[Barry Poppins]

Vote lethal before bed ?

 

[King Kong Booty]

Also everyone that’s in BOTS get your songs in

 

[R-Troop]

Troop
You seem to be the only one who hasn’t had a town read on Chris this game
Even before you brought this up you had Jean and Poyser higher as town. What is it in Chris’s game that has you off on him?

I am just looking at what I see.

Chris had one vote and it was a hammer vote (in a game without hammers). That's all I'm saying. Maybe it's just coincidence. But maybe it's scum.


I am gonna be honest, I'm not really great at saying "this guys town." I'm more of a "this guy is scum" player.

 

[Brett]

I See

What are your reads again Brett and why ?

Ugh, last time I did this I spent like 30 minutes writing a big post that no one cared about so I'll keep it short.

Town:
Booty
Poyser
Wang

Quasi-Town:
Jean
Chris

Null:
Troop

Scum:
Barry
Sky
Lethal

 

[Brett]

I will say, this Jean that entered todays day makes me fairly confident in him being town. Same aggression and bloodlust I saw from our town game together, so your shooting up my list.

Wang I was able to get into his psyche both in mafia chat and watching him play out, this game is absolutely nothing like either of his scum games. And why yes, we've talked about the ability to change. Wang did not change at all from Scum Game 1 to Game 2 and it won him last game, so why change his game up ?