South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Poyser]

@Big Jean Studd how are you feeling about smark atm?

 

[Poyser]

was getting kinda tempted to switch to booty or sky but I can't help but think his defence is a bit bad faith here

 

[Tremendez]

was getting kinda tempted to switch to booty or sky but I can't help but think his defence is a bit bad faith here

I’m not sure how it could be but if you have any more further questions of me, I’m still here.

 

[R-Troop]

dont answer this btw @R-Troop troop, i just wanna know why you chose me but you definitely shouldnt reveal what it was

Have no fear I will not reveal the role here. Or even why until later.

 

[Poyser]

I’m not sure how it could be but if you have any more further questions of me, I’m still here.

its basically acting like you would do literally nothing as mafia because you're scared shitless or something. Yes you are more timid as mafia, but clearly you still play the game. I can't say I really buy that you did anything KNOWING that it would draw attention to yourself, not least when your actions were following jean and arguing with barry of all people lol, someone who was already drawing the ire of jean. it's like the safest play ever

 

[King Kong Booty]

was getting kinda tempted to switch to booty or sky but I can't help but think his defence is a bit bad faith here

with our minimal interactions on this site I’m truly interested in how it is you read me as potentially scum

 

[Tremendez]

its basically acting like you would do literally nothing as mafia because you're scared shitless or something. Yes you are more timid as mafia, but clearly you still play the game. I can't say I really buy that you did anything KNOWING that it would draw attention to yourself, not least when your actions were following jean and arguing with barry of all people lol, someone who was already drawing the ire of jean. it's like the safest play ever

I didn’t say I don’t do nothing but a specific back-and-forth with someone like Barry defending jeans post when it was not a whole lot of marriage to it is my point. Especially when this early and day one and we can’t even do a hammer I’m just asking you to think what would be the ultimate goal of a mafia me in this particular situation would be because I went into that knowing that you had already placed the vote on me and this probably wouldn’t have looked very well, but I did it anyway because I’m trying to solve the game.

As for knowing. Every game we play now you guys complain about all my back-and-forth I do Chris mentioned it earlier in the same game. I am very mindful of when I’m going into a back-and-forth that people are gonna be watching on it specially after you’ve already voted me and you’re a strong player who has pull.

It can’t be the safest play ever if I’m literally now having a back-and-forth with you and you’re asking other people what they think of me. I’ve clearly attained the attention that I wouldn’t have wanted.

 

[Brett]

with our minimal interactions on this site I’m truly interested in how it is you read me as potentially scum

I was also very interested in Poyser's read of the T&P post sounding very Booty-Like. While I agreed with him at the time, Have you guys not interacted much on here?

 

[Chris]

its basically acting like you would do literally nothing as mafia because you're scared shitless or something. Yes you are more timid as mafia, but clearly you still play the game. I can't say I really buy that you did anything KNOWING that it would draw attention to yourself, not least when your actions were following jean and arguing with barry of all people lol, someone who was already drawing the ire of jean. it's like the safest play ever

It's your second part that's giving me more pause than him saying it. I think he said something similar as town last game and tbh has a million times before as both alignments.

But the issue is, I do think he could have believed it to be a safe play, not an attention play, which therefore by his own admission is how he would play as scum

 

[King Kong Booty]

I was also very interested in Poyser's read of the T&P post sounding very Booty-Like. While I agreed with him at the time, Have you guys not interacted much on here?

Nope he stayed mostly to mafia and I didn’t play

 

[Chris]

Smark my issue is you're acting like as Mafia you can't simply make the mistake of doing what you think is a safe play yet it actually brings attention to you.

Why is the only scenario in which you generate attention as Mafia is on purpose lol

 

[Tremendez]

I’m fine with the fact that you guys don’t believe me, but I really wish I could pull up quick topics cause I know for a fact at least Poy has been in a chat with me when I’ve been deathly afraid of doing back-and-forth with people on day one, but that’s OK.

 

[Tremendez]

Smark my issue is you're acting like as Mafia you can't simply make the mistake of doing what you think is a safe play yet it actually brings attention to you.

Why is the only scenario in which you generate attention as Mafia is on purpose lol

Cause I’m immensely aware of how not safe a back-and-forth is from me. Last game specifically there were people that were literally talking about wanting to kill themselves and all kinds of other stuff when I was going into that back-and-forth with juice. I don’t ever forget that if I’m going to intentionally grill someone like I was doing to Barry I know what I’m doing and how it’s gonna look.

 

[Chris]

I’m fine with the fact that you guys don’t believe me, but I really wish I could pull up quick topics cause I know for a fact at least Poy has been in a chat with me when I’ve been deathly afraid of doing back-and-forth with people on day one, but that’s OK.

This isn't the point we're disputing. I know this, but I'm saying the back and forth can happen even if you try to avoid it

 

[Barry Poppins]

Hard pushing Booty suspicion off of purely ~vibes~ and former game comparison when he only played D1 last time and is inexperienced just feels fraudulent. Don't think it's so out of bounds to not call you out for that. But fine let's do a booty vote, I just will need you to be the last to vote for him just to see somethin

Him playing a single day last game is irrelevant.