South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Tremendez]

I will say I think smark is probably town. That was such a dumb thought it kinda has to be genuine speculation lmao

Let's lynch smark

Vote smark

My bad. He’s right. I was confusing him with Jean.



Carry on.

 

[Tremendez]

yeah but you also dont really need to shut barry down lol

Testing the holes in his lack of consistency in his logic isn’t shutting him down. It’s trying to figure out what he’s talking about because his only reason for voting Jean in his first post was to make him do something and then he claims that there was no reason to vote Brett.

 

[R-Troop]

I think barry is town
can you join me on smark? I just caught him LYING IN 4K

Testing the holes in his lack of consistency in his logic isn’t shutting him down. It’s trying to figure out what he’s talking about because his only reason for voting Jean in his first post was to make him do something and then he claims that there was no reason to vote Brett.

See this is also why I'm on the Barrry Scum wagon.

Is it possible Smark is scum, sure. Also possible anyone is at this rate. Too early to tell.

 

[Poyser]

Testing the holes in his lack of consistency in his logic isn’t shutting him down. It’s trying to figure out what he’s talking about because his only reason for voting Jean in his first post was to make him do something and then he claims that there was no reason to vote Brett.

tbf there wasn't really a reason to vote brett. bro hadn't even posted. i don't really wanna give credibility to a vote thats based on a previous game lol, even though I understand the sentiment. I don't really think its bad for barry to consider it a bad vote

 

[Brett]

hit me

This may not be related to the Smark shit. But I am feeling town with Barry. Reason being he's been voted out either first or second the two games I played with him both times led by Jean. If he's scum there's zero way he sends a fluff vote out against the guy who typically is leading witch hunts against him, imo it's Barry just throwing some shit on the wall to see what sticks and to start movement.

As far as the smark shit, I think bro just talks a lot and naturally is going to stand on what he says even if it's wrong or untrue. I can't read it as a lie, because I don't think he even believes he was lying or knew he was.

The one thing I find bizarre is the immediate teaming with smark and jean. That's the only thing I've read from any of it. Seems like either could be using the other as a shield, but that's a pipe theory for now.

 

[Tremendez]

I think barry is town
can you join me on smark? I just caught him LYING IN 4K

I wasn’t lying. I just attributed the exact same vote to you instead of the other anti town player that tricked me last game. Apologies.

 

[Poyser]

This may not be related to the Smark shit. But I am feeling town with Barry. Reason being he's been voted out either first or second the two games I played with him both times led by Jean. If he's scum there's zero way he sends a fluff vote out against the guy who typically is leading witch hunts against him, imo it's Barry just throwing some shit on the wall to see what sticks and to start movement.

100% agree

As far as the smark shit, I think bro just talks a lot and naturally is going to stand on what he says even if it's wrong or untrue. I can't read it as a lie, because I don't think he even believes he was lying or knew he was.

The one thing I find bizarre is the immediate teaming with smark and jean. That's the only thing I've read from any of it. Seems like either could be using the other as a shield, but that's a pipe theory for now.

My problem isn't necessarily with the fact he got his facts wrong, shit happens. But he immediately tried to discredit my vote and make it look like Im doing the same thing I did as scum, which obviously wasn't true lol.

 

[Brett]

As far as the smark shit, I think bro just talks a lot and naturally is going to stand on what he says even if it's wrong or untrue. I can't read it as a lie, because I don't think he even believes he was lying or knew he was.

I know it's fairly important intel to find inaccuracies in people's stories, but I think at times it can be fool's gold. Lying implies intent, like I just misread your post and thought Troop voted you. Doesn't mean I lied, I just fucked up reading.

 

[Poyser]

Brett gonna be town too, already far far far more natural than last game

 

[Tremendez]

tbf there wasn't really a reason to vote brett. bro hadn't even posted. i don't really wanna give credibility to a vote thats based on a previous game lol, even though I understand the sentiment. I don't really think its bad for barry to consider it a bad vote

But is his any better? Jean also hadn’t posted yet and it was hour 2?

Idk I disagree. Obviously there’s no reason to believe Brett is scum, but the logic of using a consequence free non hammer to pressure someone who suspect might crack isn’t the worst idea. It feels like genuine scum hunting to me so I want to see it through.

 

[Poyser]

I know it's fairly important intel to find inaccuracies in people's stories, but I think at times it can be fool's gold. Lying implies intent, like I just misread your post and thought Troop voted you. Doesn't mean I lied, I just fucked up reading.

its the intent behind the lie (or inaccuracy) tho. He could have just defended himself based on the point i made or his own play etc, but he instead he brought up last game as a point to discredit what I was saying

 

[Tremendez]

My problem isn't necessarily with the fact he got his facts wrong, shit happens. But he immediately tried to discredit my vote and make it look like Im doing the same thing I did as scum, which obviously wasn't true lol.

Speaking of things not being true I immediately clarified I didn’t believe you were scum. I’m just saying this line of thought was incorrectly used last game. Just got my facts wrong.

 

[Poyser]

TOWN

R-Troop
Big Jean Studd
Brett
Barry Poppins

 

[Tremendez]

its the intent behind the lie (or inaccuracy) tho. He could have just defended himself based on the point i made or his own play etc, but he instead he brought up last game as a point to discredit what I was saying

If it had legimately been you it would have been a valid point.

I had nothing to defend. You didn’t have a case on me.

 

[Brett]

I do have to head out. I'll be back on a little after 9 EST.