KingMaker I Game Thread

[Tremendez]

I gave names.

I didn’t see them. Just say them again?

Otherwise you and Jeff stood out the most to me.

 

[Barry Poppins]

And the only reason Jeff shot me, in his own words, was because I was provoking him to do it, not even any real read reason, just the fact I was shitposting on him and he got butthurt by it.

 

[Tremendez]

I mean, we weren't hurting for options, just Jeff basically pigeonholed it into a decision of Me and Sky when Rugrat and Alco were also incredibly viable options.

That’s what I was saying earlier. That’s when I really felt like Jeff and Rugrat were scum together. They both parroted this lie of a choice between you and Sky.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

there was discussion about how we shouldn't kill an inactive because the person saying that was a scum read (sky iirc). its like you guys forget the at-the-time discussion to fit your narratives i swear to fucking god.

im 100% fine with lynching alco fwiw. He was not an option yesterday afaik, at least not after we had dismissed the idea of killing an inactive.


READ THE FUCKING THREAD and stop making shit up please.

 

[Barry Poppins]

And for the sake of the argument, I know Jeff will likely ask what the incentive of killing me (in regards to his reasoning) as scum would be, and the answer is, there is none, but Jeff is known to be a hothead and heat of the moment decisions happen. It happens as both scum and town.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

And the only reason Jeff shot me, in his own words, was because I was provoking him to do it, not even any real read reason, just the fact I was shitposting on him and he got butthurt by it.

thats not the ONLY reason, get the fuck off it mate. And if you think I got butthurt you were shitposting me, than good sir, you are either full of shit or dumb as a post. I have pretty fucking thick skin when it comes to trolling/shotposting, and you fucking know that

 

[Barry Poppins]

there was discussion about how we shouldn't kill an inactive because the person saying that was a scum read (sky iirc). its like you guys forget the at-the-time discussion to fit your narratives i swear to fucking god.

im 100% fine with lynching alco fwiw. He was not an option yesterday afaik, at least not after we had dismissed the idea of killing an inactive.


READ THE FUCKING THREAD and stop making shit up please.

He wasn't inactive though. He had several posts up to that point.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

And for the sake of the argument, I know Jeff will likely ask what the incentive of killing me (in regards to his reasoning) as scum would be, and the answer is, there is none, but Jeff is known to be a hothead and heat of the moment decisions happen. It happens as both scum and town.

so in your own admission, you're case on me is purely a coin flip.

 

[Barry Poppins]

thats not the ONLY reason, get the fuck off it mate. And if you think I got butthurt you were shitposting me, than good sir, you are either full of shit or dumb as a post. I have pretty fucking thick skin when it comes to trolling/shotposting, and you fucking know that

Let's point to all the times you started flaming people, especially Lethal, for minor shit.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

He wasn't inactive though. He had several posts up to that point.

he had like 2 or 3 AT MOST. find me evidence where a bunch of ppll that were relevant at the time of discussion that strongly suggested alco.

like you can say YOU suggested alco, but you were sussed, and I sussed you. so why would I care at the time who you sussed. especially if there was no actual appetite for it.

 

[Barry Poppins]

so in your own admission, you're case on me is purely a coin flip.

That's not what I said. I said heat of the moment decisions happen as both alignments, but it's compounded by your dismissal of Rugrat and Alco as options when they very much were on the table, both were active.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Let's point to all the times you started flaming people, especially Lethal, for minor shit.

but what does that have to do with me in mafia? I'd be shocked if I ever used a role out of spite? I could be wrong but I sincerely doubt it.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

That's not what I said. I said heat of the moment decisions happen as both alignments, but it's compounded by your dismissal of Rugrat and Alco as options when they very much were on the table, both were active.

But I never dismissed Rugrat as an option. I considered him the entire time I was sussing sky...you have to realise that my suspicion of him was based off of 1) his list 2) sky defending him.

Again, read the fucking day back and stop making shit up.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

That's not what I said. I said heat of the moment decisions happen as both alignments, but it's compounded by your dismissal of Rugrat and Alco as options when they very much were on the table, both were active.

But it is what you said, you even said at the beginning of the day it was 50/50 did you not?

 

[Barry Poppins]

I'm here and hopefully still alive

Oh 15 pages. Should be able to read that back. Let's go.

This was 4 pages in. I don't agree at all that you can't have anything meaningful in 4 pages.

Three posts on N0, pretty active so far.

Alco reading the thread?

You of all people even fucking commented on it.

This looks like a town post to me.

Thank you.

Can you tell me why this is the first post I've seen from you that feels like it has any substance?

It's already 7 or so pages in.

Do you have some sort of post restriction? Don't think i've seen you contributing anything meaningful to the game at all.

Not gonna lie: not showing up has become a bit of a thing for me the past couple of years.

Oh, you actually posted something meaningful. Good. Took you a fair while though.

I see Jeff has been made king. That's an odd choice, imo.

From reading back, I feel GOOD about Smark and also about Rugrat.

I feel LESS GOOD about Sky, Jeff and Char Aznable (who I guess is someone I know, but eh).
Jeff and Char A. were fluff masters until very late in the Night 0 phase. So odd that Jeff was made king. Now hopefully he'll make a wise decision, I guess.

Ah okay. That makes me feel even less good about him.

Oh hey look at that. He's not inactive.

It's almost as if you're a fucking liar, Jeff.