Anime Mafia by OMBayBay - Game Thread

[Big Jean Studd]

yawn

he was hinting that haza could be indy with a vig fake. Another pointless, window dressing post

spoiler: I doubt it

This guys gets it

 

[Big Jean Studd]

And here's why that's worrying : His take on KIF

 

[Tweet]

No I'm not thinking Indy. I'd like to see the end of night 3 in order to have more evidence, if it fits my theory I'll share it on day 4.

 

[Odo]

And here's why that's worrying : His take on KIF

Elaborate pls

 

[Odo]

No I'm not thinking Indy. I'd like to see the end of night 3 in order to have more evidence, if it fits my theory I'll share it on day 4.

Lmao, this is a blatant lie

The only other theory you can try to pivot to is that hes scum with an extra kill (or claiming an extra kill), however nobody else claimed the kill on Brad so it doesnt fit

Sorry about that

 

[Big Jean Studd]

So to me, if Tweet is scum :

He tried to create some silly little story about how KIF can't be scum unless player a b c d are also scum, saving him for later and potentially creating mislynches in between. Which to me means that KIF would be a scum watcher (or other info role) and that's how they know (in theory) that Haza is not town and want to lynch him somewhere down the line.

The other alternative, obviously, is that Tweet it town and Odo is scum.

Fairly certain of this.

 

[Banez]

No I'm not thinking Indy. I'd like to see the end of night 3 in order to have more evidence, if it fits my theory I'll share it on day 4.

So you're saying he's scum who killed his own teamm8 to give himself a cover identity?

 

[Odo]

So to me, if Tweet is scum :

He tried to create some silly little story about how KIF can't be scum unless player a b c d are also scum, saving him for later and potentially creating mislynches in between. Which to me means that KIF would be a scum watcher (or other info role) and that's how they know (in theory) that Haza is not town and want to lynch him somewhere down the line.

The other alternative, obviously, is that Tweet it town and Odo is scum.

Fairly certain of this.

So let me get this on record, you think its impossible were both town?

 

[Odo]

Hed also need to have a vigilante fake for that

No buys

 

[Tweet]

Ok well, youre not allowed to ask Haza, or indeed anybody who dislikes me if they think im scum then

See how asinine that actually is?

As if asking people if they agree with you on something youve reasoned out is scummy

You've "reasoned out" the two options you presented to Jeff and Haza, namely that I'm either inconsistent or intentionally disingenuous. The option you didn't present to them is that I actually have a point with regards to the way you're sussing me, so I can safely accuse you of asking Jeff and Haza a loaded question there.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

So let me get this on record, you think its impossible were both town?

not impossible, but unlikely. at least that's what my gut tells me

 

[Odo]

You've "reasoned out" the two options you presented to Jeff and Haza, namely that I'm either inconsistent or intentionally disingenuous. The option you didn't present to them is that I actually have a point with regards to the way you're sussing me, so I can safely accuse you of asking Jeff and Haza a loaded question there.

Well, they are free to correct me, but Im sure that anybody who reads this conversation back (thats anybody, not just Jeff) will see that youre the one skipping key logical steps in the way your reads progress

You dont have a point, and you never did

 

[Big Jean Studd]

I mean it's also just as likely Haza is just town and Tweet is just window dressing as you put it and it has nothing to do with KIF. I just really HATED that post about KIF he made and how its only possible if a b c are scum too. that theory had a lot of holes for my liking and see 0 reason for Tweet to even say it other than to create some confusion.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Regradless, I'll eat my hat if you're both town.

 

[RDK]

Regradless, I'll eat my hat if you're both town.

Odo is scum and i'm town if that helps you