Best WrestleMania Final Four: WrestleMania XIX vs WrestleMania XXX

[Chris]

​

​

​

 

[Chris]

Slightly close for me, but not really too hard of a choice going with XIX

 

[Tremendez]

This will be tough for me considering 30 is the event that got me back into being excited for Mania again.

 

[Barry Poppins]

I love XXX, but XIX needs to beat X-Seven.

 

[Chris]

I love XXX, but XIX needs to beat X-Seven.

I'll be voting for it if that makes you feel better

 

[Barry Poppins]

I'll be voting for it if that makes you feel better

Now we need to convince about 4 other people to vote for it so it wins over X-Seven.

Sorry, not sorry, Smark.

 

[Tremendez]

Any match on X-Seven is better than either Taker versus A-Train and Big Show or the Miller Lite Girls Cat Fight.

 

[Chris]

Now we need to convince about 4 other people to vote for it so it wins over X-Seven.

Sorry, not sorry, Smark.

Lmao it's extremely close for me so I'm fine with X-Seven winning as well. It stands out more historically but if I'm just rating the card for how fun watching it top to bottom is then XIX barely comes out on top.

 

[Chris]

Any match on X-Seven is better than either Taker versus A-Train and Big Show or the Miller Lite Girls Cat Fight.

Chyna/Ivory was worse than all of those except miller lite girls tbh, but those are reasons why I put 26 over 19 and no one listened

 

[Tremendez]

Chyna/Ivory was worse than all of those except miller lite girls tbh, but those are reasons why I put 26 over 19 and no one listened

Nah, Chyna/Ivory was what it was supposed to be. Chyna dominating and becoming the standard bearer for the division.

 

[Tremendez]

Chyna/Ivory was worse than all of those except miller lite girls tbh, but those are reasons why I put 26 over 19 and no one listened

I'd have listened if you said that about a show I cared about. 25-29 I give virtually zero fucks about.

But, now is your chance to say the same about 17. We'll fight the good fight together!

 

[Barry Poppins]

Nah, Chyna/Ivory was what it was supposed to be. Chyna dominating and becoming the standard bearer for the division.

That she immediately threw away and pretty much quit wrestling soon after... so it served no purpose. And it was an awful match because Chyna's an awful wrestler.

We all know it's true too.

 

[Tremendez]

That she immediately threw away and pretty much quit wrestling soon after... so it served no purpose. And it was an awful match because Chyna's an awful wrestler.

We all know it's true too.

That's not the fault of the show.

Chyna had her issues that caused her departure months later. Her last appearance was in May at Judgment Day.

 

[Chris]

Nah, Chyna/Ivory was what it was supposed to be. Chyna dominating and becoming the standard bearer for the division.

I didn't know it was supposed to be Chyna looking like she forgot what it was like to be in a wrestling ring and Ivory not able to move properly bc of the RTC gimmick and those dumbass close they had her wrestling in

And by that same logic you could say Taker's 19 match and the Miller Lite girls shit were "what they were supposed to be"

 

[Tremendez]

I didn't know it was supposed to be Chyna looking like she forgot what it was like to be in a wrestling ring and Ivory not able to move properly bc of the RTC gimmick and those dumbass close they had her wrestling in

And by that same logic you could say Taker's 19 match and the Miller Lite girls shit were "what they were supposed to be"

I mean if the worst thing on X-Seven is a quick squash match, then I think it's an open and shut case.

The handicap match and Miller Lite girls took up much more time on XIX's card.

One quick squash is still better than two duds that drag the show down.