South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[Brett]

That makes sense I had no idea what the 6-1-2 meant.

Then why on earth would Lethal as town set up trip mines for us to get fucked on by. Not to mention Jean was the hardest one pushing for Lethal yesterday, and here we are. I know WIFOM, why would lethal kill Jean it’s so obvious. Again here we are where it seems like the lynch vote is fairly up in the air, where if Jean was present. There’d probably be 4 votes on lethal so far

 

[Brett]

I’m very Occam’s razor here where the obvious solution is probably THE solution. I’d just like to talk with everyone on my usage of the gun or if we should simply lynch Lethal. I will use the gun if it’s unanimous, but I don’t want to 50/50 myself if I truly don’t have to and we have a potential solve.

 

[King Kong Booty]

Well here’s the thing you seem to be the next most likely scum read. So in most people’s eyes no matter the result of you using the gun they get the info they need. So that’s what you’re looking at

 

[Chris]

I understand the Lethal play. But I worry with how confusing AF this game is Lethal may have had the ability to turn heel Night 1, and someone else has the ability to turn heel Night 2.

I still think he could be scum. But at this point I'm willing to listen to other options. We already had one indi role, is it feasible to have a second?

That's actually what I'm leaning towards most likely too, Lethal was the D1 potential and someone else was D2 and obviously they wouldn't disclose that. It just stinks all around

As far as Indies, I know we have to have a second bc I was given the census from the host and Smark already flipped so if Grim is lying someone else still is one

 

[Chris]

I can't really figure out who I want Brett to shoot tbh but I agree he probably should and let's see what we get our of it. Lethal is the easy choice but I think there's a lot of reasons now not to go there

 

[King Kong Booty]

I’m not sold on it either but it feels like there’s a consensus leaning that way.

 

[X-Wang]

I'm not saying he should shoot Lethal but I do worry if he is being truthful here it will be something we will circle back towards.

I also thought about someone else that could be turned as well.

Do we want to direct Lethals shot or let him choose and hope he takes out a scum?

 

[X-Wang]

I'm not saying he should shoot Lethal but I do worry if he is being truthful here it will be something we will circle back towards.

I also thought about someone else that could be turned as well.

Do we want to direct Lethals shot or let him choose and hope he takes out a scum?

Also not sure who it would be.

 

[Brett]

Well here’s the thing you seem to be the next most likely scum read. So in most people’s eyes no matter the result of you using the gun they get the info they need. So that’s what you’re looking at

Can someone explain to me how I’m the next most scum read ?

So me pushing for a vote that got a scum member out is the best evidence we have on claiming I’m scum and wanting me to take a 1:1 sac on my life.

I just find it woefully convenient this theories being pushed as I was absent from the beginning of D3 and was an easy target because I wasn’t hear to defend myself.

What I did D2 was no different than what either Booty, Poyser, or Wang did.

While I 100% feel Chris is town, by evidence of everything that’s happened in this game. I just can’t really stand that Hes been sus of me from the beginning because of speculation that I would’ve entered a better way than last game if I was scum.

So the two prevailing theories on me is me getting better at the game and me voting out scum. I just physically can’t see how I’m the next scum read after lethal.

 

[Poyser]

Do you still think Booty is scum?

I’m unsure, it would be silly to not give him any credit for being on sky early. The problem is, Sky’s attitude and demeanour during the day clearly showed she was feeling down and didn’t want to play, so she almost certainly would have told her teammate to bus her. What I’m trying to weigh up is whether that would possibly have happened so early or not. I’m leaning towards no but obviously I’m finding it hard to part with my read of booty’s play, and Jean saw the same thing too

 

[R-Troop]

That's actually what I'm leaning towards most likely too, Lethal was the D1 potential and someone else was D2 and obviously they wouldn't disclose that. It just stinks all around

As far as Indies, I know we have to have a second bc I was given the census from the host and Smark already flipped so if Grim is lying someone else still is one

that's fair.

I'm wondering who would be the one to turn heel if it wasn't Lethal.

 

[Poyser]

Can someone explain to me how I’m the next most scum read ?

So me pushing for a vote that got a scum member out is the best evidence we have on claiming I’m scum and wanting me to take a 1:1 sac on my life.

I just find it woefully convenient this theories being pushed as I was absent from the beginning of D3 and was an easy target because I wasn’t hear to defend myself.

What I did D2 was no different than what either Booty, Poyser, or Wang did.

While I 100% feel Chris is town, by evidence of everything that’s happened in this game. I just can’t really stand that Hes been sus of me from the beginning because of speculation that I would’ve entered a better way than last game if I was scum.

So the two prevailing theories on me is me getting better at the game and me voting out scum. I just physically can’t see how I’m the next scum read after lethal.

I don’t mind this defence at all to be fair but then I town read you anyway lmao

 

[King Kong Booty]

I’m unsure, it would be silly to not give him any credit for being on sky early. The problem is, Sky’s attitude and demeanour during the day clearly showed she was feeling down and didn’t want to play, so she almost certainly would have told her teammate to bus her. What I’m trying to weigh up is whether that would possibly have happened so early or not. I’m leaning towards no but obviously I’m finding it hard to part with my read of booty’s play, and Jean saw the same thing too

I mean that feels like you're still going off of my day 1 and Jean was mostly mad cuz I had said that I would kill whoever put the nail in my coffin regardless of what they say to me and I have since realized that the final nail probably won't be scum just some misinformed town..
Also Chris and Wang being seasoned players and who know me well seem to feel I am town and Chris is most certainly a unanimous town read so why would you doubt his read on me?

 

[King Kong Booty]

unfortunately for me the only scum reads I had besides sky all seem unplausable at this time

 

[Brett]

Also apologies for the aggression, but I want to solve this shit. And I’ve also had quite the day, it took a bit to set in realizing what the whole gun thing means. I keep thinking of it as a chance to kill scum during the day, but I also am dealing with my mortality in the game and that’s something I don’t want to give up that easily.