South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[R-Troop]

I think the things that are annoying you about him is just his natural personality and why he annoys you irl and that's town Barry. If he didn't seem bad to you, it would actually be suspicious.

Me, Jean, and Poyser have all agreed this is how we read him fwiw but I also won't act like it's a 100% success rate

I look at it as I legit read him scum. but if he dies and he's town then well the game becomes exponentially more pleasant and peaceful. Therefore win/win.

 

[Chris]

I look at it as I legit read him scum. but if he dies and he's town then well the game becomes exponentially more pleasant and peaceful. Therefore win/win.

That's not really how the odds work sadly, the more town goes it's way easier for scum to win. Remember in our first game together that we actually needed to get it right on D2 to not lose even tho we prevented the scum kill for N1

 

[Barry Poppins]

I look at it as I legit read him scum. but if he dies and he's town then well the game becomes exponentially more pleasant and peaceful. Therefore win/win.

 

[King Kong Booty]

I look at it as I legit read him scum. but if he dies and he's town then well the game becomes exponentially more pleasant and peaceful. Therefore win/win.

@Chris we call this move the Michael Rappaport

 

[Brett]

Giving Brett the gun is a decent choice to me. I'm the most back and forth for him myself so if he dies he dies and at least I don't have to worry anymore lmao

I know I've played 2 scum games and naturally the same way I keep townreading Booty is how people are going to naturally just scum read me, but like outside of the Barry flip from me. You have put no pressure on me, asked me no real questions, or directed anything but saying "i just feel so iffy on Brett". I've been so pumped to play this game as town and help solve, but I wish there was something I could do to earn your trust because inherently I get where your coming from, previous game bias be damned, it's how I make 90% of my reads. That's why to me, I'm not even casting scum doubts on you, it seems to me like your just paranoid town and that's fine. Just gives me bad vibes to hear you say you want me to die LMAO

 

[Barry Poppins]

 

[X-Wang]

Giving Brett the gun is a decent choice to me. I'm the most back and forth for him myself so if he dies he dies and at least I don't have to worry anymore lmao

What is it about Brett that annoys you the most.

In the last game in the chat he told Poyser how he is a wildcard and will just pick fights. So he just went about his own way but he did tend to over indulge things about what we were doing.

I find him the co plate opposite of that and how he acted. Now he could have decided to to change up if he us scum. He has seemed pretty consistent to me this go around.

 

[King Kong Booty]

@Brett did you get the role of one of the emo kids? cuz that post was depressing

 

[X-Wang]

Is this what you have to do because you got voted off the council?

 

[Chris]

I know I've played 2 scum games and naturally the same way I keep townreading Booty is how people are going to naturally just scum read me, but like outside of the Barry flip from me. You have put no pressure on me, asked me no real questions, or directed anything but saying "i just feel so iffy on Brett". I've been so pumped to play this game as town and help solve, but I wish there was something I could do to earn your trust because inherently I get where your coming from, previous game bias be damned, it's how I make 90% of my reads. That's why to me, I'm not even casting scum doubts on you, it seems to me like your just paranoid town and that's fine. Just gives me bad vibes to hear you say you want me to die LMAO

That's all fair, the posts I actually analyzed had me thinking your were town. But the suspicious more comes from thinking you would conciously course correct what went wrong prior and if you unluckily drew scum again, I think you'd make those improvements so it's hard for me to rate different play as town play if that makes sense

That's why I'd give you the gun also, if you live and can keep it and my paranoia is just wrong then that's good for tow

 

[Barry Poppins]

 

[Barry Poppins]

 

[X-Wang]

That's all fair, the posts I actually analyzed had me thinking your were town. But the suspicious more comes from thinking you would conciously course correct what went wrong prior and if you unluckily drew scum again, I think you'd make those improvements so it's hard for me to rate different play as town play if that makes sense

That's why I'd give you the gun also, if you live and can keep it and my paranoia is just wrong then that's good for tow

Ok I get what you are saying and that makes sense

 

[Chris]

I'm not gonna entertain this much and I'm so sorry this happened to you

But I posted my POE earlier, Sky, Lethal, Brett

 

[Barry Poppins]

I'm not gonna entertain this much and I'm so sorry this happened to you

But I posted my POE earlier, Sky, Lethal, Brett