South Park Mafia: Who Killed Butters? [COMPLETED]

[King Kong Booty]

but if people wanna lynch me that’s cool too
Just whoever puts the final nail in my coffin will regret it

 

[Tremendez]

but if people wanna lynch me that’s cool too
Just whoever puts the final nail in my coffin will regret it

That’s an unsubtle soft and I copy that. It won’t be me.

 

[King Kong Booty]

I wish we had a game of Booty as scum to tell how he acts as it. I rely so much on previous game information, so Booty to me just reads town because that's all I've known him as. If he didn't vote for me early, I would've been stunned lmaooo. Even him unvoting me made me a bit sus, but again I don't think there's much to that read

I explained why I unvoted you

 

[Big Jean Studd]

but if people wanna lynch me that’s cool too
Just whoever puts the final nail in my coffin will regret it

HMmmmmmm

 

[King Kong Booty]

That’s an unsubtle soft and I copy that. It won’t be me.

When am I ever subtle about anything?

 

[Chris]

The smilies are just for Juice to keep track of who's made 10 posts I'm pretty sure, we don't need to focus on that lol the second ones are added once we hit 10 I assume, first were after 1 post.

Wouldn't read into the Mafia troll posts either, it's pure WIFOM to try and guess who would send them

 

[Chris]

Why did you guys decide Brett's reaction was good exactly after the initial push? I saw Jean said something about him not trolling and trying to solve but I don't think that's unlike his scum game either? I thought he was town as a spectator last game for similar reason until like the last day or so and I don't think he doesn't make joke posts as town either, I'd have to look back at the town game he had closer tho, I think most of my thoughts are still centered around his scum games

Can you elaborate on that and I think Booty as well who unvoted

 

[Chris]

Also will hopefully go back and actually read once gameplay actually started to be of more help but I'm here now at least to discuss whatever lol this is what stuck from me on my skimming

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Why did you guys decide Brett's reaction was good exactly after the initial push? I saw Jean said something about him not trolling and trying to solve but I don't think that's unlike his scum game either? I thought he was town as a spectator last game for similar reason until like the last day or so and I don't think he doesn't make joke posts as town either, I'd have to look back at the town game he had closer tho, I think most of my thoughts are still centered around his scum games

Can you elaborate on that and I think Booty as well who unvoted

Im just satisfied for now , he has really shitty entrances as scum and acts very off best which I didn't sense

I would not say he's the towniest like poyser claimed but he has not mistepped immediately as he tends to imo

 

[Chris]

I'm not comfortable reading Grim at all. He admitted to me the last game we were both town that even when he's town and he thinks someone is scum, he grasps at anything and everything to try and convince people of that, and I always sus when I think someone is reaching to prove some kind of concrete read. Genuinely can't reconcile that lmao my old rule was he's more reasonable as town but pretty sure his last scum game that I spectated recently he played the exact same so in my head I said fuck it he was town lmao

I can say most of his posts on Jean regarding the Brett push were what I would deem not very reasonable from Grim, I just gotta figure out if that's town or scum still

 

[King Kong Booty]

Why did you guys decide Brett's reaction was good exactly after the initial push? I saw Jean said something about him not trolling and trying to solve but I don't think that's unlike his scum game either? I thought he was town as a spectator last game for similar reason until like the last day or so and I don't think he doesn't make joke posts as town either, I'd have to look back at the town game he had closer tho, I think most of my thoughts are still centered around his scum games

Can you elaborate on that and I think Booty as well who unvoted

I changed my vote cuz he didn’t do his super talk to much gimmick and didn’t overreact and also the odds he’d pull Scum 3 of 4 times seems improbable

 

[Chris]

Im just satisfied for now , he has really shitty entrances as scum and acts very off best which I didn't sense

I would not say he's the towniest like poyser claimed but he has not mistepped immediately as he tends to imo

Yeah let me look back at the pure entrances at some point (probs not tonight) bc I think I'm basing more on after he settles in

 

[Big Jean Studd]

Also didn't mind his grim analysis , I think scum him would have been inclined to pick a side or sling more mud at least

 

[Brett]

Why did you guys decide Brett's reaction was good exactly after the initial push? I saw Jean said something about him not trolling and trying to solve but I don't think that's unlike his scum game either? I thought he was town as a spectator last game for similar reason until like the last day or so and I don't think he doesn't make joke posts as town either, I'd have to look back at the town game he had closer tho, I think most of my thoughts are still centered around his scum games

Can you elaborate on that and I think Booty as well who unvoted

I dig this post from Chris. I know my scum games probably are in the front of everybodies minds (because it's been 2:1) , but like even in my town game I would troll and pushed for a Lethal vote because I got super heated at him and wasn't even playing the game right. I don't think it's a fully succinct read out of Jean and while I appreciate the town read, I still think it wasn't too much to just fully clear me and not continue pushing the heat on me. I agree with Chris here.

 

[Big Jean Studd]

I'll admit nothing he said hadn't been. Already kind of said though but ya I dunno , nothing jumped out at me that required immediate further pushing , and the game got started as I wanted