"Lawyer Fucked Me" A Shawshank Redemption Mafia Game Presented By Barry (Game Thread)

[Fuji Vice]

Well, Looch/Troop is the PoE in this case, and barring any shenanigans we could easily get one then the other. Neither has covere himself in glory. Troop's play at end of day 3 was, as I say, horrid, but I think he's more likely to be thinking on his own as he's consistently suspected me. Meanwhile Looch was fine to work with me D3 and then turned right on me because he knows me dying is the only way he wins

That being the case, I think I'd be more apt to go Troop first. As I mentioned earlier, Troop seemed a lot more keen on following my info without question, whereas Looch at least brought up the possibility of a bad cop or bad investigation.

They could reasonably have guessed that Smark was going to be investigated N2 given that he was on the outer reaches of suspicion

Oh, they for sure hit Tremendez on Night Two and it was excellent timing. I just fail to see them having the wherewithal to use it on Wang on Night One when he wouldn't be a likely investigative target AND I'm not even sure the role allows for that.

 

[Fuji Vice]

Anyhow, we have something like 14 hours left, so there's no reason to rush. I'd like to hear more from Wang.

 

[Wang Chung]

Unless Jean borrowed Sky his vest, Mafia going for Jean N2 is what makes Sky have the weakest case of being supposedly Town.

If Avie can doctor the same person twice in a row, she should doctor Fuji the upcoming night. We lynch Sky today, if Sky flips town, Fuji investigates either Troop or me. Whatever the result would give town most likely the W next Day phase, unless GF is in play

• PoE - Process of Elimination

Stop with the outside specs.

Smark gave Jean a commute.

Jean made sky commute above the game board. Nothing can harm her, she cant do anything.

Avi said here sky take this pill to keep you safe. It fell to the ground because Sky wasnt there.


Jean cant give his BP to anyone. His BP could have been used either night as There was one kill Night 1 and one kill Night 2.

Mochi was a mod kill.

Sky had no clue she was put un the sky so she could still be scum.

 

[Wang Chung]

Here's my question.

Why is Wang confirmed to be town? I get he was role copped. But so was Smark and we know how that worked out. It's conceivable Wang was framed too.

Why are you just assumed town because you could have bussed your teammate and followed Looch all game to gain his favor. I at least have a result on me that was done Night 1 and the least likely for town to be messed with.

 

[Fuji Vice]

In re-reading Brett's flip, the framer can only make people show as mafia, so that rules out framing Wang to make him show as town. He could still be the GF but that's lower on my list of possibilities than it just being Looch or Troop. They were both on the Tremendez vote, as was Sky, Ax and myself, so that doesn't help us much.

I will point out that Brett (known mafia) voted for Sky. That doesn't clear her, but it's food for thought.

 

[Sky]

That being the case, I think I'd be more apt to go Troop first. As I mentioned earlier, Troop seemed a lot more keen on following my info without question, whereas Looch at least brought up the possibility of a bad cop or bad investigation.

Oh, they for sure hit Tremendez on Night Two and it was excellent timing. I just fail to see them having the wherewithal to use it on Wang on Night One when he wouldn't be a likely investigative target AND I'm not even sure the role allows for that.

Reding Brett's role, it can only change Town to be read as Mafia, rather than the other way around. Wang is 100% clear.

Also, re: bolded. That's probably more reason to suspect Looch when I think about it. Anyone pushing the "fake cop" narrative looks awful because scum would LOVE to hang the cop. And suggestions of framers would be indicative of TMI

 

[Sky]

I will point out that Brett (known mafia) voted for Sky. That doesn't clear her, but it's food for thought.

Except when you consider that scum would have been happy with either me or Smark hanging D3, so scum voting on me is in character

 

[Loochquake]

Let me explain the order of events that happened.

NIGHT 2
Jean kills Poyser
Jean uses his gifted commute on me (This is why there was spec that I was scum, as I could not have performed the scum kill that Night)
Scum team attempts to kill Jean - hits his vest. (There is nothing else in the game that could hit his vest)

I have to go back and look, but wasn't it mostly just Smark and Jean who discussed the commute/scum speculations about this situation.

...and I still have no idea why you being commuted would clear you in any way. It makes no sense to assume there was no scum kill, just because you were commuted. Maybe I'm getting it all twisted, but yea...

Meanwhile Looch was fine to work with me D3 and then turned right on me because he knows me dying is the only way he wins

Sure... I was definitely not "fine to work with you" on D3. Like at all.

 

[Sky]

Sure... I was definitely not "fine to work with you" on D3. Like at all.

You were civil. Troop flavoured every single interaction with me with "SKY IS SCUM GET HER". That's the difference

 

[Loochquake]

You were civil. Troop flavoured every single interaction with me with "SKY IS SCUM GET HER". That's the difference

If that is the only thing you meant with "fine to work with me", then yea, I agree on that part.

 

[Sky]

If that is the only thing you meant with "fine to work with me", then yea, I agree on that part.

And the point I'm making is that Troop was convicted and loud about it throughout, and your reservedness seems to contrast with your desire to get rid of me ASAP right now

 

[Fuji Vice]

Except when you consider that scum would have been happy with either me or Smark hanging D3, so scum voting on me is in character

Oh for sure, I'm just covering all bases.

To your other point about Wang, he is 100% clear....unless he's the GF. Do we really believe mafia would have a GF role given the other roles they had? Framer and Roleblock would tend to make me think the Don is just the shot caller, or perhaps it is just shared among them.

Perhaps it would be best for all remaining players to give their top suspect lists. I'm not so sure I'm willing to believe the Tree Stump role claim, but on the other hand, it seems more plausible than having 6 Vanilla Town players. Booty and Mochi were both VT, so if we're to believe everyone else still alive then we're left with 3 more. It's much more apt to believe that Sky is telling the truth and one of Looch/Troop/Wang is lying about being VT. If we eliminate Wang, it HAS to be Looch or Troop. So...

Looch
Troop
Sky
Wang
Ax
Me

 

[Loochquake]

And the point I'm making is that Troop was convicted and loud about it throughout, and your reservedness seems to contrast with your desire to get rid of me ASAP right now

Well, I hope people wouldn't think I would be that stupid of a player to act like this, even if I probably already gave enough fodder for that theory throughout this game.

 

[Sky]

Oh for sure, I'm just covering all bases.

To your other point about Wang, he is 100% clear....unless he's the GF. Do we really believe mafia would have a GF role given the other roles they had? Framer and Roleblock would tend to make me think the Don is just the shot caller, or perhaps it is just shared among them.

Perhaps it would be best for all remaining players to give their top suspect lists. I'm not so sure I'm willing to believe the Tree Stump role claim, but on the other hand, it seems more plausible than having 6 Vanilla Town players. Booty and Mochi were both VT, so if we're to believe everyone else still alive then we're left with 3 more. It's much more apt to believe that Sky is telling the truth and one of Looch/Troop/Wang is lying about being VT. If we eliminate Wang, it HAS to be Looch or Troop. So...

Looch
Troop
Sky
Wang
Ax
Me

SK was already investiagtion immune so that's a lot of redundancy

 

[Sky]

My suspect list is Looch/Troop. Everyone else is clear